Podcast
Christian Westerlind Wigstrom – Monoova.
Dexter Cousins is joined by Christian Westland Wigstrom Co-Founder and CEO of Monoova for episode 146 of the Fintech Chatter podcast.
Dexter and Christian first connected in 2018 when Christian did a presentation on the future of Payments title The Death of Payments 2030. Christian presented a day in the life of a woman named May to predict how payments will have changed by 2030. Christian argued that while payments would not die, paying would.
5 years on Dexter invites Christian to share an update and discuss if any of his predictions are coming true. Or has he changed his mind?
About Christian
Christian is the Co-Founder and CEO of Monoova, a Sydney-based, B2B payments automation platform and a member of the Fintech Australia Board since November 2022.
Over the past five years, Christian has led the building of a company servicing domestic and international tech-first platforms such as Wise, Nium and a significant portion of the Australian digital-currency industry. To date, Monoova has processed $75bn through its API-driven solution, more than half of which since the start of FY22. Christian has been a finalist for the ‘Outstanding Fintech Leader of the Year’ by Fintech Australia in 2020, 2021 & 2022.
Born in Sweden, Christian obtained a Master’s Degree in Economics, and a PhD in International Relations from Oxford University in the UK. Following a position as speech writer and economic advisor in the House of Lords in London, Christian moved to Zimbabwe to work as Chief of Staff at a Harare-based agricultural group with operations across Southern and Eastern Africa. He arrived in Sydney in late 2016
About Monoova
Monoova is a leading, Australian, payment service provider. Via API integration, Monoova provides businesses comprehensive automated and real-time payment solutions that address and resolve traditional pain points of payment processing and management.
Through, Monoova’s customisable solution, businesses can send, receive, and manage funds transfers more efficiently, reduce costs and improve their customers’ payment experience.
Servicing domestic and international tech-first platforms, Monoova has processed over $75bn.
As the first mover in the market on the new domestic PayTo transaction type earlier this year, Monoova already provides ‘real-time direct debits’ at scale in the market.
https://www.monoova.com/
Subscribe Newsletter: https://www.linkedin.com/newsletters/fintech-leaders-7092732051488980992/
Connect on Linkedin: https://bit.ly/3DsCJBp
Links from this episode.
- Monoova
- Christian Westerlind Wigstrom on LinkedIn
- PayTo at Australian Payments Plus
- Monoova on powering PayTo for Wagepay
- RBA and DFCRC media release on the CBDC pilot use cases (March 2023)
- Primer
- Intersekt, the event where Christian first told the story of May
- Tier One People
Christian Westerlind Wigstrom on Fintech Chatter.
- Christian Westerlind Wigstrom on Monoova (2020), episode 24, on a world where payments just happen as we move through our daily lives
More on payments and digital currency on Fintech Chatter.
- Gabriel Le Roux on Primer (2023), the episode Dexter mentions
- David Lavecky on CANVAS (2023), on the RBA’s eAUD pilot
- Chris Jewell on Zepto (2024), on real-time account-to-account payments
- Tristan Dakin on the future of cross-border payments (2025), on Wise, a Monoova client Christian mentions
- All Fintech Chatter episodes
Full transcript.
Lightly edited for readability — filler words removed, wording otherwise unchanged.
Dexter Cousins
Fintech Chatter, brought to you by Tier One People, leaders in fintech executive search.
Welcome to Fintech Chatter, the show I connect with fintech leaders for a bit of a chat. Today I’m joined by Christian Westerlind Wigstrom of Monoova. And of course, I forgot to mention, I’m your host, Dexter Cousins. If you’re coming back, thanks so much, and if you’re new to the show, make sure you give us a like and a subscribe and follow us on your favourite podcast player. Christian, welcome back.
Christian Westerlind Wigstrom
Thanks, Dexter. I feel like I was never really away, but now sitting there in front of you.
Dexter Cousins
You weren’t away, right, because this is kind of like our annual podcast, which normally happens because we do the Finnies, and we haven’t done it this year. And I think we did three in a row with you, and then last year you finally bloody won, and you weren’t there at the awards. What’s going on?
Christian Westerlind Wigstrom
I mean, winning Fintech Organisation of the Year for Monoova was an amazing feeling and one of the things I’m incredibly proud of. But I had the best possible reason for not being physically at the awards.
Dexter Cousins
C’mon.
Christian Westerlind Wigstrom
Which was I was with my family back in Sweden for the first time since COVID.
Dexter Cousins
Right.
Christian Westerlind Wigstrom
So if ever I, like the only reason that I could come up with that wouldn’t give me overwhelming FOMO was probably that reason.
And so happily I got to celebrate, and people back home in Sweden who had no idea that I was so cool found out that he’s winning awards. It was great. I’ve got to be honest as well, I was a bit bored, right, because I was asking me the same questions every damn year: why aren’t winning?
Dexter Cousins
Yeah, no, no, no, you, it’s part of the kind of People’s Choice Awards where we ask the same questions. But my mind’s back to when we did our very first podcast together, which was actually three years ago now. And the reason why I asked you on to the show was because you kind of had, and I think we first connected in around about 2019.
Christian Westerlind Wigstrom
Yeah.
Dexter Cousins
Yeah, when you did a presentation on the future of payments and payments 2030, and it was this just really awesome kind of narrative around how our lives would be with instant payments technology in 2030. And I’ve invited you back on because a lot has happened in that last three years, and I want to kind of see if that is still on track, whether you’ve changed some of your thinking around that.
Christian Westerlind Wigstrom
I mean, I feel like a lot has happened even since the beginning of today, so yes, a lot has happened in the last three or whatever years. So yeah, that presentation was sort of Monoova’s coming out. It was in October 2019. It was obviously at our favourite event, the Fintech Australia Intersekt in Melbourne. We had just become Monoova by brand, logo and all the rest of it, and realised that there are lots of larger players, more established, more technology were already behind them than we had.
So what did we have? Well, I thought we had a beginning, so a really cool product. We’re already serving Wise at that time, or TransferWise. So I felt like we had a bit of sher just from that. But maybe what we needed to do to stand out was to do something that wasn’t just showing graphs pointing up towards the right and talking about all the wonderful things we were. Rather, we’re trying to tell a story of, first of all, why should someone care about a company like us, and second of all, how do we make what we do relatable. And obviously those two things really belong together.
Payments is to my knowledge one of the few things in life that everyone has experience of. I mean, there probably a few other professions, few other services and products you can say, well, everyone knows about that, everyone has some kind of contact with. Food, I imagine. Everyone probably has some kind of contact with sewage and waste management. And then payments, it’s sort of that. So while you can tell the most boring story in the world around API-driven payments automation, and you can be happy that that is where it ends, and you probably reach a great audience of technologists and others, you missing out on the much greater narrative, which is how does it impact all of us, regardless of how, if and when we have any sense what goes behind the scenes.
So I know that by the time I wake up, when I meet someone who isn’t my wife or my two children, they will have transacted in all likelihood. They bought a coffee, taken a bus, whatever it is. So the story in 2019 that I was telling was, well, how do the trends that we already started seeing then, and I’m sure we weren’t the only ones who were looking to the future, but how were the trends going to change an everyday experience? So I followed a woman, I think her name was May at the time. I came up with what seemed to be a general future-oriented name with not too much sort of cultural baggage either way, and I, being a stalker isn’t a really good way telling a part narrative around payments.
Dexter Cousins
Fair enough.
Christian Westerlind Wigstrom
And then I sort of followed her for part of her day, and I came up with this 2030. She was having dinner with a few friends, I think, and like what on the way to having that dinner. I must say, even though we’re since that story almost four years further along, we almost past a half year mark here, or halfway mark to 2030, I still think it holds.
The main message, and one of my friends were joking about this for a long time, they thought it was trying to be semantically witty, but it was that, well, payments will not die, paying will die. So the title I think was something like the death of payment something, and it came out, it was the paying, it’s the action, the activity of doing something with your hands that will disappear.
So while we’ve come a long way from giving people pieces of metal that are gold and silver, we’re still doing something. We are tapping a phone, that’s probably the most sophisticated it get. We’re doing something, so we’re still paying, the action is still there. But what I was arguing back in 2019 was that that will no longer be the case. It will truly happen in the background.
And then there were lots of different things. I remember talking a lot about Internet of Things that were sort of doing a lot of the paying for you. So the milk is talking to your calendar, so it knows that you’re not going to be on holiday this week, therefore order some more milk. And there be lots of these things that sort of come together.
What wasn’t maybe quite as clear to me then, nor could I claim to have absolute clarity on it now, is, well, how exactly will that work? But what has happened over the last three and a half or whatever it is years is that I think we’re much closer to knowing what that answer looks like. And it sounds like I set this up back then, psychic or lots of other things, to then at some point talk about PayTo. I’m not going to do a big plugger on PayTo here. We all know it’s awesome and that Monoova is a leading provider.
But PayTo is this real-time direct debits essentially in the Australian market only. Obviously it will look different in different jurisdictions. But when I provided the second chapter of this death of payment story, so chapter one was told in 2019, chapter 2 was then told almost two years later because of COVID. 2020 there was no Intersekt, so instead the Intersekt 20120 sort of ended up happening early in 2021. At that point PayTo had become a thing and people had a rough understanding what it could mean.
And what I thought was exciting was to understand that a lot of the things that I’d spoken about May day, when May was walking in and going to the, she was stepping out of a, I remember this now, she was stepping out of a car. It was sort Uber experience. You don’t have to pay for the Uber, you have to do the paying in Uber.
Payment is there, paying isn’t there. And then she goes into a supermarket and she just walks out, think of like Amazon Go, which at that point was really cool and new. And then she goes from there to a restaurant. She doesn’t have to wait for a waiter to come up with a merchant terminal, and then there are lots of kerfuffle because there’s the receipt, the terminal is being used for someone else. And then she goes there from to a fun fair, and then she goes home from the corner market, whatever it was. There’s a lot of the idea there was that we should think of the Uber experience, but everywhere, all the time.
And at the moment you might well have an account that allows you to go to Amazon Go, but it’s not your Uber account. So the thought here was that this essentially Uber account then keeps paying for you as you go in and out of various purchases. It’s as if that one wallet just kept tracking you and tracing you, and at the same time, in parallel, you have your Internet of Things stuff at home that ensures that you have, you don’t even need to go to a shop for a lot of these things, which again, it’s not super special, you can think of online shopping, but it’s still doing something, and that I think will disappear.
So in all, one tends to exaggerate the change in the short term and underestimate change in the longer term, as a very well-known moniker. I think got it roughly right. I don’t think we’re going to be too far off. We’re not talking about flying cars by 2030. We’re just talking about this activity that’s been with us for 40,000 years is no longer going to be an activity. It’s going to something that happens in the background. Every once in a while of course you run into it, but you’re going to go, oh, they’re actually asking me to tap something. Just like we now, if someone asks you to swipe something, we just go, yeah, what’s going on here? It’s actually a sign of something being wrong, as opposed to an everyday experience. I think we’ll have the same experience with that.
Dexter Cousins
So we’ve seen in that time as well some, you kind of, amazingly, crypto still here, Bitcoin’s got stronger, but they’re now being seen I think less as payments mechanisms, certainly for high volume transactions. And we’re now kind of moving more towards this kind of institutional, yeah, almost like tokenisation, digital assets. What role do you see kind of Monoova playing as those spaces continue to evolve and the technology continues to evolve?
Christian Westerlind Wigstrom
So we at Monoova have been working with the digital currency space for a long time. In fact, my first ever client, for memory, was a crypto exchange back in April 2017. So we have been at the margins, never ourselves dealing with the digital asset itself, but I guess been following this stuff. I think it’s been clear for most people for some time that it is primarily a digital asset, it’s an investment object rather than a means of payments.
I’d say hardliners would argue that that’s just a function of the immaturity of it, and frankly at some points we’ll have sort of price discovery and so on. I’m not really sure I believe in that, but it doesn’t mean something is wrong with it. It’s just that the use case that might have thought of initially is not actually the strongest use case. But what at some point became really fashionable to say, if you were in the know, was to say, oh, I don’t really believe in Bitcoin, but I like blockchain.
For a long time there was just this amorphous thing of Bitcoin equals blockchain equals probably some nefarious activity, and you buy stuff on Silk Road or something. And then it moved from being nefarious to still being Bitcoin equals blockchain, blockchain equals Bitcoin. And that changed again, and then people were able to separate those two.
I still think there is clearly, I mean, I don’t have to be particularly clever to figure out that there is demand for Bitcoin and other cryptocurrencies. Clearly there are lots and lots of people owning them, to huge market cap values. But what we’re seeing, as you’re right, is this institutional exploration of how you can create actually means of payment, and that is happening both at a private level, so you have various private actors creating, I don’t know, stablecoins left, right and centre. Some of them have seemed to be able to keep the peg against often the US dollar, others have been spectacularly poor at keeping a peg.
But the idea is them is if you’re creating a stablecoin, then investment in them expecting appreciation is going to be the most boring activity in the world. It’s like having a snail’s race. If you’re investing in a peg against that same peg, then ideally a return is zero.
But because there have been times when the peg doesn’t hold, again you start to feel a little bit nervous. And if you’re not asking for any additional value from it, you’re not asking for your money be worth more by the time it gets to you from me, then you just want it to be safe. That’s the whole point of what we’re looking at here.
So having truly low counterparty risk, certainly after things like FTX and Terra, whatever they called earlier, seems to be quite attractive, and a lot of governments have gotten on to this. And so Monoova’s role here in a very practical sense: Monoova, it’s one of, I don’t know, two handfuls of participants that were selected by the RBA to be part of the CBDC, so central bank digital currency pilot, which we’re very proud of, working with a client or two of ours to test a use case, which has to do with cross-border flows and ultimately our clients’ customers having a direct claim on the RBA.
I mean, talk about removing counterparty risk. You’re removing not just risk with us, you’re removing the risk with our banking partner, and all of a sudden it’s you, private individual, calling the RBA and saying, can I have my money, please?
Now that may not work at a wholesale, true rolling out, in a true rolling out phase, but for now, in a pilot, it’s one of several I think really interesting use cases. And there are few of them. I think there was an article today about CANVAS having completed at least the first transaction on their use case. I think they’re 14 in total. Well, sorry, I know that there are 14 in total. Most other parties are probably a bit larger, so we have g z, CBA, Mastercard and the like, but some of them are also on the smaller side where we think it’s really interesting to be there.
Our role here is I think to be part of, I guess, creating not just a use case but an understanding of why would anyone need this. So not just what can be done, but what should be done. If I was a policymaker, I would think of an eAUD or some CBDC as my wettest ever dream. I mean, imagine having programmable money, and you’re a fiscal policymaker and you need to stimulate the economy, expansion in your fiscal policy. In the past you were praying that the $5500 you give every family would be spent within some period. You hope that maybe they’ll spend it within the first two weeks, maybe four weeks, because that’s, I mean, if they don’t spend it, then what’s the stimulus?
Just handing up money ends up in a mattress and probably build a bank balance sheet somewhere. Doesn’t have to be bad, but it doesn’t give you what you need. Imagine instead if you handed out to everyone, handed out 500 eAUD to everyone, and that was programmed to expire, bit like a voucher really, after.
Dexter Cousins
And not work in pokie machines.
Christian Westerlind Wigstrom
And not work in pokie machines. You can’t spend on alcohol or on bad music or whatever a patronising government might decide to do. But it is a really powerful tool, and look, immediately you will have people shouting about anything from privacy to just practical things. Let’s say you program it, it can’t be used beyond two weeks and you can’t buy alcohol. Okay, so you go and you buy nappies. Like, what then? Does it mean that after the first transaction you can spend it on anything you want for however long you want, because otherwise, like, why would anyone accept that?
Otherwise no one would accept an eAUD, because they go, well, it’s going to be worth this in 3 days and I happen to be really thirsty. So there are lots of questions here, and you can’t have these sort of subcluster currency islands where now you can use these eAUDs here and these eAUDs. But it is a way of having very effective policy levers, so that could be exciting. That’s from a government perspective, and I think we need to really factor in the government’s preferences here, because they’re going to be the ones ultimately guaranteeing it and issuing these things.
And I should say immediately, I’m not ruling out that there a very strong case of private ones too. But right now I think, because of the uncertainty in broad crypto markets, everything is tainted with a brush that is probably a bit too broadly. So right now I think it’s a good moment to focus on this other area, to show just the power of the technology rather than thinking it’s all FTX in the making.
But so for government I think there is this positive way of doing more with a tool you already have, is just way blunter right now than it could be. Doesn’t change the concept of money. It’s not a new thing, it’s a new technology. Just like moving from, as I said, piles of metal to piece of paper to digits on a card doesn’t change the concept of money, it just changes how you deliver it and how fast it gets delivered and all these other things.
There might also be a defensive part of this, which is thinking, again from a government perspective, which is, I imagine an Australian policymaker, certainly at the foreign office of similar, would find themselves a bit annoyed if they travelled to Fiji on some state visit and realised everyone is using an e-renminbi or some other currency that might be deemed to be at least less than friendly. That is not at all an unlikely situation. It is very possible that China or other parties will seek to at least unsettle the US dollar, or possibly more locally an Australian dollar, to be the obvious reserve currency in the jurisdictions that we’re talking about. And so even if the government here or in some other country sort of didn’t see the particular use for it, almost have to be forced to have something.
Because sooner or later someone else will have it for you.
And you don’t want to find yourself without options. So that’s on that side. And then, as I said, for consumers, for usess private individuals as much as for companies, of course the fact that you could at least potentially have a direct claim on the RBA is incredibly efficient and incredibly safe. Bank runs would be a thing of the past, and we thought they were, but they were not.
Dexter Cousins
Yeah, I was going to ask you about that actually, because that’s one thing that kind of we haven’t facted, and bank runs used to take weeks if not months, now they take minutes.
Christian Westerlind Wigstrom
Yeah.
Dexter Cousins
Where do you see, what other risks do you see with instant payments and being able to move money in a fraction of a second, any amount of money in a fraction of a second? Do you see there are some other risks that perhaps we haven’t thought of or considered deeply enough yet?
Christian Westerlind Wigstrom
Of course, absolutely. I would imagine that any technology bears with it risks, and I would imagine we’d be idiots to think we have thoughted by them all. So the, I guess, categorical answer is yes. What could there be? I mean, if we use the example of bank runs, there was a famous bank run in London in 1780s or something, where the way they got around, the way they avoided being actually toppled by the people standing in line, was by paying out everyone in farthings or pennies or whatever it would have been at the time, but like one after one.
They needed people to feel progress was being made, and if you stood in line you would get your money.
So the way to do that was, rather than giving people, I don’t know, £500, here is your very big piece of paper, go and colonise India, they gave them individual little coins. So there was a sense, look, they’re honouring their obligations, I’m just going to be steady, and people that stood in line for long enough felt, you know what, this is clearly going on, I’ll come back tomorrow morning. And they did that for long enough that they managed to get the support they needed from another bank. That’s gone.
You can’t say I’m going to give you, look at your bank balance on your, you don’t have to go to an eAUD for this, right? If you say CBA, could you please give me my $2,000, and they say not an issue, keep looking at your NetSuite, sorry, your NetBank app, and you see one cent after another dropping in, you’re going to start thinking this is worrying.
In a way that you probably weren’t quite before. So of course things that move fast tend to have different consequences and things to move slowly. At some level we, speaking incredibly collectively, tend to love convenience, and we tend to love convenience over lots of things that sort of rationally we might think we value higher or highly, whether that is privacy or other things. When something goes wrong with privacy then all a sudden we’re all arms in the air and how dare you and so on. But then if something doesn’t really go wrong, then we please, we keep putting our pictures on social media about stuff we probably shouldn’t be telling others about.
And I think the same thing goes with money. We’re clearly very happy to work with credit cards and so on, even though everyone can see everything, over cash, which is really the one where you can’t really track as much, because it’s very convenient. I mean, if anything, an eAUD is going to be incredibly trackable, just as all blockchain currencies are. You can really track it, but we like it.
Dexter Cousins
Well, yeah, that’s, I’m curious, right, there seems to be this massive push at the minute around CBDCs and digital ID, particularly around kind of what I would call crypto native.
Christian Westerlind Wigstrom
Yeah.
Dexter Cousins
And you think, well, you’re on Twitter the whole time telling everybody about your bags that you own and what you’ve sold. Where’s privacy an issue for you? I mean, it’s kind of, it is a bit of a, I do find it a bit of a strange one, that we live in this world where basically everything is tracked.
Christian Westerlind Wigstrom
Yes.
Dexter Cousins
And yet somehow there’s this big resistance around CBDC when credit card spending’s tracked. We’ve been using digital payments for decades.
Christian Westerlind Wigstrom
Of course. And an argument that’s often levied in those cases, sort of against sceptics, is, well, if you got nothing to hide, then what’s the issue? Which is not a very strong argument. Just because you don’t hide anything doesn’t mean you want to share everything.
Even if my personal life is super happy jolly and everyone who knows me loves me, doesn’t mean that is something I need to share with everyone. You don’t have to be half through divorce for it to be something that should be not shared. And the same thing goes through personal finances. You might be in great financial health, doesn’t mean you have to tell everyone that, nor would you have to tell them when you’re not. But I do think we want to choose when something becomes public, and I’m not sure we always do. I personally know that I will see terms and conditions from Apple or Amazon or something and just go, yeah, whatever, which is not clever. I know it’s not clever and yet I do it.
I don’t think that cryptocurrency is primarily viewed as a privacy mechanism anymore though. I think it was at one point, against, it was Silk Road times, but it probably wasn’t in the very, very early days. I mean, the way I understand it, and I am not a crypto native and there are trillion people I know who could do this more justice than I can, but I understood that the white paper by Satoshi was primarily a response to the 2008 financial crisis, where they didn’t believe banks could take care of their money.
Dexter Cousins
Which was kind of very similar to the Luna crisis and the FTX crisis.
Christian Westerlind Wigstrom
That’s right. But what’s one interesting thing, I sort of felt that that was truly in the past, that the Satoshi crowd had let this thing out in the wild and people had picked it up and they’d done good and they’d done bad things with it, but no one was really an ideologue anymore. No one was really saying I’m doing this because I don’t believe in the banking system or the Fed. That felt pretty far removed from it. But then you see the banking crisis over the last few months with a few failed American banks, and Bitcoin was really appreciating in that time. Now, I’m not in the know enough to say it was because Silicon Valley Bank collapsed, but the coincidence of timing was remarkable. You’d think be a sort of flight to safety, and maybe that’s what it was.
There was some crowd who thought, well, I, Bitcoin is frankly safer than putting USD into an American bank that yesterday were talking about conquering the world.
Dexter Cousins
Yeah, and I think that’s kind of really incredible narrative, right, and proof point of, whether you believe in it or not, the reality is it hasn’t gone to zero.
Christian Westerlind Wigstrom
Yeah.
Dexter Cousins
When many thought it would, and it keeps on doing what it does.
Christian Westerlind Wigstrom
That’s right.
Dexter Cousins
And I think that’s kind of that immutability, I guess, is something that people take a lot of comfort from.
Christian Westerlind Wigstrom
Absolutely. I think we should also remember that while things are moving very fast, and you started off saying lots has happened in the last three years, and I said, yeah, well, actually, frankly, since this morning, both of which are true, we’re still talking pretty short time periods.
So if we give Bitcoin as a forerunner cryptocurrency some kind of, I don’t know, date of birth in 2008 or so, actually don’t know exactly when it was, let’s say it’s roughly, and then we’re talking 15 years. That’s not a long time. If we look at the mutation of use cases that even in my brief lifetime in Australia, which is, it’s probably about as much as long as DVD’s got.
Dexter Cousins
Yeah, it’s probably right.
Christian Westerlind Wigstrom
Yeah, that’s right. I mean, it is younger than Facebook, it’s younger than a lot of things, and frankly no one uses Facebook. Well, that’s not true. I think we’re probably seeing a generational shift there too. But it’s younger than a lot of things that probably number of people are seeing as an obvious part of their every day, and this has not been around for long enough. I mean, I’ve been out of school for longer than this has existed.
But it is, as we know, often difficult to extrapolate too far on to little time series data. There is this famous quote where the Chinese foreign minister, I’m not even attempt to pronounce his name, I think it’s Li, so I did the attempt, was asked in 1972, what do you think about the consequences of the French Revolution? And he said, it’s too early to tell. And obviously Western media thought that was hilarious. I mean, talking about long-term thinking, China, oldest country and sort of civilisation a continuous sense in the world, lots of comments on that. And then it’s since been disproven that he was actually not talking about the 1789 revolution, he was talking about the 1968, as in the, right, like the screaming in the streets of Paris just three years earlier.
And I think we might make a similar, I think the risk here is that we’re commenting on things that have happened a bit too late or too recently. And it would be, I think, an odd position to hold that sort of cryptocurrency is gone or spent. I think there’ll be, certainly what we’ve experienced at Monoova and what I’ve seen is that there’s a proliferation of use cases that to me speaks to the strength of a technology rather than a weakness.
It to me doesn’t mean that whatever was there first is so bad that people do other things. It’s more people understood, wow, we can use this for lots of other things.
So I think we’ll keep seeing that. What exactly wins in the end, like what’s the standard? Are we going to be seeing only CBDCs really in the market and a few rogue private stablecoins, or is the CBDC in fact a fad, it’s just that it’s happening right now and therefore we attribute more value to it than we should? I don’t know, but the technology seems to be doing rather well.
Dexter Cousins
And we’re really, so one of the other things that you talked about a lot was, I guess essentially, what I would call e-commerce, that when you talk about the death of payments. We had Primer on the show a few weeks back. I know that you’ve partnered with them recently. What was the thinking behind that?
Christian Westerlind Wigstrom
Sorry, good peg, well done. So yeah, super happy to be partnering with Primer. So Primer are UK-based. They probably tell me off for sort of classifying them incorrectly. I think of them as like a payments orchestration layer, from what I understand.
Dexter Cousins
I call them the Zapier of payments.
Christian Westerlind Wigstrom
Okay, yeah, that makes sense. And they’re very clear what they do and what they don’t do, and they are truly like a software service.
They’re not actually managing money themselves, from what I understand. So it made immediate sense when we started looking at them to explore like what can we do together. So Monoova has obviously been now transacting on PayTo for a few months, and we’re excited to be properly up and at scale with PayTo in the Australian market. We’re also coming up with a credit card gateway in the not too distant future. And for both of these, for us really great new additions to our general products, we Primer made sense.
So what Primer allows you to do is, as an existing Primer customer, you using them as your sort of checkout, sort of, and you can see I want to have, I want to use that credit card gateway and that credal gateway, or you might even use, I want to use Alipay and whatever it may be. They have lots and lots of different payment providers behind the scenes. And with us, all of a sudden you can, and I want to use PayTo.
So you don’t actually have to do a technical integration with us. You can get PayTo through them, so you’re already integrated, it’s already in your e-commerce site, and you sort of toggle on. Now, there are few asterisks around this, but from a customer, from our client perspective, it becomes so much faster to be up and running, and it’s not this big decision, should I be investing this many years, but it’s truly, so many years is obviously ination, should I be investing this many dev hours or dev days of doing PayTo.
That won’t suit everyone. Primer will have a certain target market that is more e-commerce focused. Maybe some of our current target clients and target markets who truly build their own ERP systems and ledgers and everything, they probably want to have a deeper integration directly with us, and that’s obviously fine. We’re public with Wagepay already in the market on PayTo, and we didn’t need anyone in between us.
But what’s also going to be exciting for us is that we’ll have our own credit card gateway on there. So you don’t have to use PayTo if you don’t want to. If you feel that for your customers it’s particularly important that they can pay you using cards, well, now you can, through a very easy-to-use interface, really very high quality product, where we are literally sitting behind their facade. Use Monoova to service you on cards as well as of course PayTo or autom matcher, PayID solution and account number solution, direct debits, whatever you want. Like, you get it all in one place. And Primer is helping us with that, both to get the card product into market through our partnership and to broaden the market for our existing product site. So very exciting. We think that’s going to be fun.
I personally believe that the future sits with PayTo and real-time rails, both here and elsewhere.
But I also think that not all businesses can move to PayTo tomorrow, if nothing else because not all accounts are reachable. But even if we stretch to be a year or two or three or five, there’ll be everything from institutional inertia to just very well established patterns of behaviour. It wouldn’t make sense in my mind for a utility company to use PayTo, seem like they get money directly, no need for direct debits and find out three days later whether money for that gas bill was there or wasn’t there. You can do these things very quickly, but I think I’d be naive to think that these often very large companies could move between now and tomorrow.
So the great thing with having a very broad product suite, including BPAY in fact for us, and obviously our thir entry, even RTGS, NPP, etc, is that we can take you along. This becomes like a bridge. So at the beginning of your life with us you might be using our BPAY and direct debits and a little bit of PayTo and NPP, and then over time you realise that you can direct your customers to use the payment method that you think is best for them and for yourself.
And you don’t have to change providers, you’re on the same platform.
Dexter Cousins
You get to know as well, well, we were talking about Singapore before we hit record on the show.
Christian Westerlind Wigstrom
Yeah.
Dexter Cousins
Every time I go there, there’s like four or five different terminals you kind of ask you to use, depending on the cod that you’ve got.
Christian Westerlind Wigstrom
That’s right. I don’t think that’s what it’s going to keep looking like. There are lots of things we used to have lots of and then now looks incredibly arcane. If you were really important and you had a corner office, you probably had six phones on your big desk. Now that would look like you are a few decades behind time. Decreasingly will there be a need to have lots of different pieces of hardware for something that frankly can happen probably between your phone and someone else’s phone.
But I think the cost still matters, and the cost matters often for the merchant or the, yeah, the recipient of those payments, because they often do incur a cost of some kind.
Either by virtue of having to rent the merchant terminal, mean in a more conventional setting, or, I don’t, paying some subscription fee to access to some kind of payment service. Like, there could be lots of different costs involved. So for them I’m sure it really matters. And if you’re a small business and you’re incurring either 10% sort of cost of acceptance fees or 5% cost of acceptance fees, you’re going to go the hard press to choose the 10%.
So I think in that sense it’s definitely going to matter. And one great thing about PayTo is of course that one as cards are, unless you’re sort of looking for that thing that only cards can do, and for credit cards is probably the credit, and there might be a few loyalty aspects and so on, as a means of payment, if the merchant can get not the guarantee of money today but actual money today.
And you can get it, rather than paying percentage of value, you get it for cents, for stuff that’s being more than $40, $50, you’re going to be thinking that that’s the way I’d rather have.
Dexter Cousins
Right.
Christian Westerlind Wigstrom
Money right now. So by the time my consumer, my customer, sorry, leaves my shop, whether it’s online or in person, by the time they leave I have money that I can pay my bills with right now. And the guarantee of money from the card schemes is pretty solid. We can be pretty sure that the card schemes are going to give you money, but they will give it tomorrow, and that’s just because that’s how those systems are built up. There is a role to play there.
But PayTo is going to show up as a pretty cost-effective way of paying, and it’s going to show its potential well and truly beyond the immediate intuitive use case of real-time direct debit. That’s how we come to think of it, I think, very quickly, and then we start thinking, well, what else? Well, again, there are some e-commerce settings where we’re not probably hard at this point to imagine using PayTo possibly to buy a pair of shoes online, because what if they show up in 3 days time or in 12 days time, and only one of them shows up, or they’re two left feet, or they’re not the colour I thought.
We need to probably work on the liability component of it. So obviously with chargebacks and cards you have a way of getting your money back if it wasn’t what you thought. That’s not obvious exactly how that’s going to work for PayTo quite yet. But lots of other things are obvious. If you are buying immediate access to a service, why wouldn’t you want the money to leave right now, because it is anyway, this just doesn’t show up right now with the merchant, or would you just do it that way instead? And if the merchant is incentivising you by saying, look, if you use cards it’s going to be this cost of acceptance surcharge on top of that, but if you use PayTo it’s for free.
So I think we’ll see that. And there was something else you were raising about, oh, was at least cost routing, that’s right. So cost will matter at all times, and as I said, even back then it was part of trying to get some attention. We were a dwarf amongst s, still are in many ways. I think we will see on the basic sort of Hing factors of payment services we work, it’ll be hard to maintain very high margins.
But where it gets very attractive, both for us as a business selling the services and I think for our clients buying these services, is that because of the data richness, because of what is possible to see and control with these kinds of payments, you’re not just coming to us because we can move money from point A to point B. You can go to bank teller and ask them to run over to the next bank physically, and they can do that too. It’s the way we do it, it’s, as we said, the controls in place, it’s the data that comes with it, it’s the full protection, it’s the prevention from all kinds of things that might go wrong.
So I think increasing the payments is going to be something that happens in the background, not just for the consumer.
But even for the payment services company, that’s going to be that, yeah, of course money, but actually the bigger things are all these other ways. Not quite there yet, because there’s lots of value even in just moving to new payment types, PayTo being obviously the biggest example right now. But I think that’s exciting.
Dexter Cousins
Yeah, it’s fascinating though, right, that the kind of pace of innovation in the space is always pegged back or kind of drawn back because of the risk element.
Christian Westerlind Wigstrom
Yeah, and that makes sense.
Dexter Cousins
Yep, and there are risks, but so often the thing that brings about the risk might, the risks are, there’s just gazillions of them, right? You’ve got regulatory and compliance risk, but then there’s all the stuff that you’ve talked about, right, which, technology failures, like there.
Christian Westerlind Wigstrom
Yeah, technology failures, branding issues, kind of all sorts of stuff. Of course, yeah, and I think one would be stupid to dismiss that and think, well, doesn’t apply to us. You can be very well-resourced business in Australia and have, yeah, all kinds of issues with cyber crime, as we know, as of late. And so why would we think that a small company would somehow be immune from it? No one is, doesn’t matter how big or small you are.
But I also think that often the kind of technology that brings about a new array of risks often, not always, has a kernel to the solution or the mitigant to those risks. And even if that technology doesn’t, maybe another one, yeah, does. Another fa, it happens to be another Chinese thing, but when China started putting in telep in the 70s, there was a real concern that maybe the world would run out of copper, because all the wiring would be done out of copper, and then we got fibre instead, and it is no longer an issue. And so what is a concern at one point might turn out to be quite a small one at a later stage. Doesn’t mean it’s foolproof. Maybe there is no fibre optics to help us with these issues or equivalent, but probably something.
Dexter Cousins
It feels very much, and from what I see, that the technology is already in place, and a lot of the predictions that you made are actually already happening today in that kind of 2030, you kind of, the day in the life of May that you presented. A good example would be, yeah, going into a restaurant, tapping your phone, getting the QR code, ordering from the menu, getting the food delivered, it’s paid for, your walk out.
But then it kind of feels that also there are these huge issues that need to be resolved first, before we can take that kind of next step, particularly around digital ID. We’ve had some massive data breaches, which we probably, I don’t know any, myself included, I don’t know anybody who hasn’t being a victim of.
Christian Westerlind Wigstrom
It’s crazy, yeah, me too, right?
Dexter Cousins
I mean, that is just, it’s insane really. But you look at that and you kind of, you think, yeah, we’ve still got a long way to go before it can be ubiquitous and seamless. Where do you, what do you see is the big thing that needs to be tackled before that whole 2030 vision becomes a reality?
Christian Westerlind Wigstrom
I pause because I don’t think there’s like one thing, right answer. There lots of different things. It is a matter of habits is one thing. We should also state there’s nothing sort of theological about invisible payments. There’s nothing that says that’s the only way the world could go. But if you look at the last few thousand years or whatever it is of payments, innovation tends to go towards more convenient.
And what’s the most convenient thing in the world? I don’t even have to think about it.
That’s the most, you were saying already, now we can tap a phone at a table instead of asking for a waiter. Shame really, because sometimes the conversation with waiter can be fun, but equally it’s very convenient. But you’re still tapping. Yeah, imagine not.
Dexter Cousins
Oh, my kind of Amazon Prime account is just, it’s godsend, right?
Christian Westerlind Wigstrom
But I think some things are going to be driven by, most things ultimately I think are driven by consumer behaviour and expectations. But as responsible societies, you want to make sure that before you let loose a very fast car, you make sure they have really good brakes. I mean, the ability to drive fast is as much a function of having great brakes as it is about having a strong engine. And so that will apply here too. In our world, brakes probably equates to regulation, probably equates to having the right kind of licensing regimes. Obviously in Australia a lot of things are changing, which I think is great.
But we’re not that far away from this, as you said. Maybe the thing that’s the most sort of Jetson-like, to use a very old reference, most similar to sort of predicting flying cars in 2030, it’s probably all the Internet of Things stuff.
That the fridge buying your milk. But that too doesn’t feel too far off. The question is just how much do you think that that of simplifies your life. This might still fall over the next six years.
Dexter Cousins
Yeah, I kind of, you, this isn’t, kind of dwell on, you, some really unfortunate kind of outcomes for businesses, but the kind of milk run, the kind of convenience delivery stuff. My first job when I was a 14-year-old was working on a milk run.
Christian Westerlind Wigstrom
Yep.
Dexter Cousins
And I lost my job because it went bust, right?
Christian Westerlind Wigstrom
Yep.
Dexter Cousins
You couldn’t make that work by how youing 14-year-old kids and paying them peanuts, and I don’t see where that’s actually changed. I think there’s a few reasons for that. One is just that the unit economics don’t stack up.
Christian Westerlind Wigstrom
Yeah.
Dexter Cousins
But also, I don’t know about you, but actually like to go and do grocery shopping.
Christian Westerlind Wigstrom
Totally. I mean, the perfect pilot for let things come to you rather than you go to them was, I don’t know, COVID isolation.
You couldn’t go anywhere, all a sudden everything had to come to you, and people I’m sure found it really relaxing in the first few weeks and months. At some point they couldn’t wait to get outside.
Actually move, actually be more than two and a half person within 5 km radius or whatever the rules were. So yeah, there are lots of things that can surprise us. But ultimately I think it comes down to how want to spend our time. So the competition for everyone at all points is not necessarily another company or another person doing what you’re doing and possibly doing it better. Competition is what else you can spend your time on.
So competition could be in the form of, like if we think of Monoova marketing, there are some really formidable businesses out there that doing things that impress me as much as they annoy me. But they’re not necessarily what I’m competing with. If I have a Monoova post or ad somewhere, I’m also competing against a cute kitten you can spend the next five seconds on.
On YouTube. So I’m sort of competing with everything.
Not just people that, and they are competing with that kitten too.
And so here again the question becomes one, well, if we take paying out of your everyday life, you have somehow, somewhere gained time. We’re not telling anyone what to do with that time, obviously we can’t. Most people probably going to be watching that kitten with thatal time. But at least it becomes a choice. And we’re sort of approaching the limits of optimisation once we start giving people a few seconds here and there.
But I do remember, sort of tie back to that 2019 talk of mine, I was trying to put it in some kind of order of magnitude that might pique someone’s interest. I’m going to try get the maths right here. But I said that there were roughly two billion cups of coffee being sold every day in the world, which was true then, 2019, who knows what it is now. And I just postulated that it takes 15 seconds to pay for a coffee. That’s what it was, was two billion cups of coffee, and let’s assume that it takes 15 seconds, I don’t know, fiddling with your wallet, tapping or coins or wherever you are in the world, 15 seconds to pay for it. So that’s 15 time 2 billion, that’s 30 billion seconds. And by total coincidence there about 30 million seconds in a year.
So that means as a humanity we’re spending a thousand years per day paying for coffees. That’s just one of several things we pay for. So by removing that one purchase time of 15 seconds, I know lots of ifs here, if we remove just that, then in of itself that has given humanity a thousand years back per day. With that we could cure cancer, or we could watch kittens.
But at least we’re not fiddling with wallets.
Yeah, and if it’s a matter of sort of optimisation, it doesn’t have to mean that people become isolated. It doesn’t mean that we go back to sitting in our bedrooms. It just means that while you’re standing somewhere or talking to someone, you don’t have to say, sorry, I’m going to put you down for two seconds, or bear with me, I’m now at the till paying. You keep having the conversation. Maybe just maybe you become slightly better friends. Maybe just maybe you make an observation that will change something for someone, because really banal the paying.
It’s important, but it’s not super exciting.
Dexter Cousins
Yeah, and I tell you what, if you could save me time that I spend at these self-served checkouts at Coles and Woolies, man, I think that’s going to be the greatest frustration of my life, standing there waiting for somebody that’s flashing, say, yeah, didn’t you, there’s a problem with it, you could. I think I must spend about 40% more time at those things than just having somebody check out and going through paying for it.
Christian Westerlind Wigstrom
Well, look, maybe it’s more than a thousand years a day.
Dexter Cousins
Yeah. Well, Christian, it’s been awesome to catch up with you. Really fascinating chat. Really good to talk through just what this last four years has brought up, right? And it’s, I mean, most, I think pretty much everything that you spoke about is on that path. I don’t see anything that you think, yeah, well, that was crazy, that was wrong, that’s not going to happen.
Christian Westerlind Wigstrom
It definitely feels decreasingly crazy, yeah, I’d say. Still six years too.
Dexter Cousins
We get loads of cool people listening the show, a lot of them very top talent. If they’re interested potentially in a career at Monoova, what’s the best way for them to find out?
Christian Westerlind Wigstrom
Well, there’s obviously monoova.com, and then there’s LinkedIn, and then there probably a thousand other ways that they can get all of me, because my personal data was stolen twice this year.
Dexter Cousins
Yeah, there you go. So if you’re on the black market for jobs, you should have Christian’s details, check op this.
Christian Westerlind Wigstrom
Yeah.
Dexter Cousins
And obviously we get lots of founders, people within the industry listening to this, could be potential partners, customers.
Christian Westerlind Wigstrom
Absolutely.
Dexter Cousins
What’s the best way to reach out?
Christian Westerlind Wigstrom
Same things. But also we are often talking to people in our industry. We don’t want to be confined obviously to just fintech peers, but we do love fintech peers and we speak a lot to them. So chances are I might have spoken to a few of them before, so they will know already how to get hold of me, and everyone else has said LinkedIn is probably the fastest.
Dexter Cousins
Yeah. Well, listen to in 44 countries, so you never know, it might be somebody new to the market. Well, it’s been fantastic to catch up. Thanks for listening, folks. As always, you can connect with me on LinkedIn and Twitter, and if you’re coming back, thanks for your support. If you’re new to the show, make sure to give us a like and subscribe, follow us on your favourite podcast player, and if you have the time, please leave us a review. It really helps me in getting great guests like Christian onto the show. Until the next episode, keep well.
Fintech Chatter is presented by Tier One People, leaders in fintech executive search. We’ll you find world-class fintech leadership talent to build world-class fintech benches, and you can find out more at tieronepeople.com.


