Skip to main content

Podcast

Alan Tsen, Fintech Radar on Fintech News.

February 7, 2023 · Hosted by Dexter Cousins

Fintech Chatter News is back for 2023!

In this new monthly format, Dexter chats with a friend of the show about the BIG Aussie Fintech news of the month.

This month’s guest is Alan Tsen of Fintech Radar

Follow Alan on Twitter https://twitter.com/alantsen

As an OG of Aussie Fintech Alan was GM of Stone and Chalk and Chair of Fintech Australia.

More recently Alan held the Director of Revenue Strategy role for African Fintech Chipper cash.

And Alan has now gone back to his Fintech roots by heading up IAG Firemark accelerator program, FMX

Alan is also the author of the excellent Fintech Radar newsletter – Make sure you subscribe!

In this edition of Fintech Chatter News Dexter and Alan cover:

Follow us:
Apple: https://apple.co/3D7NsPt
Spotify: https://spoti.fi/3IzSViQ
Subscribe and like on Youtube: https://bit.ly/3tBlRmE
Connect on Linkedin: https://bit.ly/3DsCJBp
Follow on Twitter: https://twitter.com/DexterCousins

Links from this episode.

Alan Tsen on Fintech Chatter.

More from this episode on Fintech Chatter.

Full transcript.

Lightly edited for readability — filler words removed, wording otherwise unchanged.

Dexter Cousins
Welcome to Fintech Chatter News, presented by Tier One People, leaders in fintech executive search. Follow us on your favourite podcast player or Fintech Chatter TV on YouTube.

Welcome to Fintech Chatter News. We’re back for 2023, and I’m Dexter Cousins, and I’m s… That’s right, today’s guest is Alan Tsen. He was last on the show in April 2020. As an OG of fintech, Alan was GM of Stone and Chalk and chair of FinTech Australia. More recently Alan held the director of revenue strategy for African fintech Chipper Cash, and Alan has now gone back to his roots by heading up IAG’s Firemark accelerator program, or FMX. Alan is also the author of the excellent Fintech Radar newsletter, which is my go-to source for everything on fintech. Alan, great to see you, my friend, and thanks for joining me today.

Alan Tsen
Dex, it’s so good to see you. It’s been a moment. I didn’t realise it was that long ago, but I was on the show. Thanks having me back. We did a crypto special, I think.

Dexter Cousins
That’s right.

Alan Tsen
No, I remember it. I just didn’t realise it was that long ago, and how things have changed. It was just before everything started going to the moon, I think.

Dexter Cousins
Was it? It literally was.

Alan Tsen
And yeah, and again, how things have changed.

Dexter Cousins
They have. Yeah, it was awesome. Well look, it is awesome to see you today, and we’re going to do a few things. There’s some news for us obviously to talk about. I want to talk to you about Firar Clabs, want to talk to you about Fintech Radar, and I also want to talk to you about your career, because it’s been such a fascinating one, and one that I think a lot of people would do well to kind of look at some of the things that you’ve done.

But before we go through all of that, the big news this last week or so, I guess let’s start off with the good news, which was the capital rise of Hnry, Series B, 35 million. What were your thoughts on that, Alan?

Alan Tsen
Firstly, congrats to the team. I mean, raising 35 million in the current climate is phenomenal. I think one of the things that’s really interesting at the segment that Hnry’s in is, and sorry for those who haven’t heard of them, basically doing SME banking and some ancillary services around that. So if you go to their website, the messaging is a lot around helping smaller businesses with tax and accounting, and then there’s some ancillary financial services, right? So I sort of bundle them into that banking space, maybe rightly or wrongly. Like to hear the founder talk a little bit about that maybe one day as to his views.

But nonetheless, I think that space is super interesting, and one of the open questions at the moment with that banking space is, what is the entry point, right? Like, how do you enter that market, and what’s the value proposition that’s really going to stick over the long term?

Dexter Cousins
Yeah, right.

Alan Tsen
So those are sort of the open questions. It’s super interesting to see a big round. 35 million is non insignificant round in the current climate, like I was saying earlier, but again, something must be working there if investors have come in for that kind of check size. So yeah, but a very interesting space nonetheless.

Dexter Cousins
I had James on the show last year, and it was one of my favourite podcasts actually of last year. Few reasons. I mean, we just sat and had a beer and put the video recorder on, and it was just really, yeah, it was just really good. But I think the other thing is that I just really love a bootstrap story, and when James talked me through the origins of himself and his wife started with Excel spreadsheet, now you got a $35 million raise. It’s amazing.

But I think one thing that you said there which really kind of resonated, and I think might be one of the reasons why, and things for founders to look out for, is that thing around entry point. Because if you look, what, three, four months ago, probably one of the biggest deals that happened last year was the MYOB Flare acquisition, and again, similar kind of premise around what is the entry point. They use superannuation and a whole host of benefits, but then to offer all these ancillary kind of services and to get into then a payroll of these huge organisations, where you got a ready-made customer base of thousands of people.

Alan Tsen
Correct, correct. And I think that’s the key question, right? And sorry, just to clarify that for people who maybe aren’t deep into the weeds around why entry point’s important is, to my opinion anyway, it’s important because the value proposition that you start with is probably the hypothesis around where the most value is going to be created to acquire your first set of customers, your original customer base, right?

And so one hypothesis that other startups have sort of taken is that the core value proposition is an account, a bank account, right? The debit card, the account. It’s a little bit smoother as an experience, et cetera. Others have taken lending as the entry point, right? And so those entry points really matter, again, just because that’s your first set of customers and the base of your business, right? And if you don’t get traction of there, there is no Series A, there is no Series B, there is nothing more than that, right? And so that’s a very important hypothesis you want to really run down, right, to start with. And yeah, I mean, we can spend all day talking about…

Dexter Cousins
We could. We were talking just before the recording, and it’s a real bittersweet time for me at the minute, has been probably for the last six months or so, where on one hand I’m kind of congratulating clients and my network on capital raises, and then on the other hand I’m kind of consoling my network who’ve either lost their job or their business has gone bust. And unfortunately announcement on Friday of Openpay going into receivership. It really does feel like at the minute it’s almost like this kind of two-speed economy and Aussie fintech, the world of the haves and the have-nots. What’s your take on that, Alan?

Alan Tsen
Yeah, I think that’s an astute observation. Probably has been true for a while, to be honest, right? And I think it’s not uncommon if we zoom out to other ecosystems as well, right? There are those fintech stars, the ones that we all have heard of, and the other ones that are finding a little bit more challenging. And now I think in the current environment that’s just exacerbated, right? So there isn’t an easy 2 million that you can raise with little to no traction. That just doesn’t exist, right? And that number could be whatever that number is, but there isn’t that early round of funding available in the current Aussie climate any case, or those bridging rounds, right? They’re just not appearing as often for startups.

And I think, coming back to Hnry, that’s a good example of a startup that clearly something’s working there, and the investors are happy to come in and double down on that opportunity. And that’s what I think, coming back to two-speed economy comment, Dex, that’s what we’re going to see.

Dexter Cousins
Yeah. Openpay, an example of a fintech that listed on the ASX fairly early in the piece. Unfortunately it’s not worked out. What do you think might be some of the kind of implications of this, kind of from an investor perspective?

Alan Tsen
Firstly, big call out to all the employees, right? It’s often forgotten in this type of news that there are people who will probably lose their jobs, right, and we’ll be back in the market looking for their next role, through no fault of their own, right? And so condolences, good luck in the next role, right? And so that’s the first call out.

And then beyond that, I think it’s a tough market, right? This is probably not going to be the last fintech startup that has to close the doors. We all know BNPL was a crowded market, and a really tough market, just because of that saturation of players. And then beyond that, slightly tougher economic climate. All the combined factors.

Dexter Cousins
Yeah. I mean, there’s been so many headwinds, right? Rise in interest rates, not just a small rise, but like unprecedented kind of rise. And it just feels like there’s been a lot of factors conspire against that space. I guess there was some legitimate kind of questions around, is it actually a standalone business, or is BNPL a feature within a super app, or part of what a bank can offer? Do you think that’s eventually where we’ll see this end up, buy now pay later?

Alan Tsen
Yeah, it’s a tough one, right? So slightly contrarian view: I think buy now pay later still has a lot of legs, right? So I think as an entry point, coming back to that comment around entry point, I think it’s a disruptive entry point. Historically, short history so far for buy now pay later, but historically that was an area that banks just would not touch, right? And we’ve seen banks take a long time to push out a buy now pay later part here in Australia, and it’s probably, let’s be honest, fairly subpar from the Big Four. So from that perspective it’s still an interesting entry point, right? There are headwinds, but when you have a clear path that you can attack a incumbent with, that’s interesting. A whole bunch of other challenges that again we could talk all day about, but I still think it’s interesting.

And then we’ve talked, I think most conversation centres around consumer-facing buy now pay later. That spot, the B2B payment space, is still incredibly arcane, right? And buy now pay later is a format that customers see in their day-to-day life and understand, and when you flip that up into a business context, it can be interesting. And we’ve seen globally that’s where round in buy now pay later started to centre around, is that kind of model, more in that SME.

Dexter Cousins
I’ve actually been using it more over the last six months I think I ever have, and it’s not necessarily because I’m getting into debt. It’s because it’s just easier to manage a budget. I’m still big on buy now pay later. I think I agree with you. I think there’s still a long way to go, and it is a case of weathering the storm, and maybe he’s a little tweaking of the business model as well, around just making it more, I guess, kind of congruent with the high interest rate environment that we have.

Alan Tsen
Yeah, exactly, exactly. And I think it’s still one of the more interesting consumer vectors for startups, right? So the story is not over for buy now pay later. I think we’re still in the early innings.

Dexter Cousins
Cool. Now, you kept giving me some really good little kind of lead-ins to what I wanted to talk to you about next, and I kept knocking them back because I was just engaged in this discussion with you, which is around the difficulties of fundraising. And I think one of the things that are kind of outlets that I think is really important for founders to look at now, particularly in the environment that we’re in, are accelerator programs, which is kind of one of the reasons why I wanted to get you on the show in the first place, was to talk about FMX. So kind of first of all, can you tell us a little bit about the kind of origins of FMX and how it came about?

Alan Tsen
Yeah, so FMX is the accelerator program that’s run out of the Firemark Collective, which is IAG’s innovation and venturing function. So as probably most people know on this call, IAG is Australia’s largest general insurer, and I head up that accelerator program. So the sort of history there is, much like other corporate accelerator programs, the idea being to bring the outside world in, and to do that through a program.

So this is now we’re entering our fifth season as I step into heading that program up, and in previous seasons that’s exactly what we’ve done. We’ve brought the outside world in, provided a ton of value to the startups through a 12-week program, trying to connect them with internal stakeholders at IAG for opportunities with respect to their businesses. And then also we do something slightly different to other accelerator programs. We run these things called sub programs, where we bring some of the best thinking from inside of Firemark to the startups. So we have a engineering and data science program, where we bring some of our engineering talent to help out the startups and help them conceptualise what they’re trying to build to the insurance sector, and we do the same on the design side.

So lots of value that we’re trying to bring to the startups. And I think most importantly, coming back to that fundraising element, we don’t take any equity. This is about us trying to support startups, and then on the flip side trying to bring that innovation to IAG, to show them what’s out there in the world, and to really, yeah, I think challenge thinking as well. So a slightly different program, but in many ways your classic corporate accelerator as well.

Dexter Cousins
Yeah. Who are some of the kind of notable previous kind of businesses who’ve been on the program?

Alan Tsen
Yes, so last season we had a company that our venture team invested in. So worth calling out that Firemark has a CVC, a venture that invest, and they invest in a startup called Transp, right? So the sort of in and around insurance base, but nonetheless an important startup in the context of the program. So yeah, we’ve made some investments in the past as well. But one of the things that we’re really, I think, proud of with the program is that we’ve been able to connect startups and really help them explore insurance use cases, in some instances never having thought about insurance use cases.

Dexter Cousins
I remember when, it might have been Firemark themselves, invested in Air Tusa, and at first I was scratching my head, and then it made perfect sense, right? You think the kind of holistic value chain of an insurance business, most of it is making good on the promise. Costs their money, right? It’s not just given a lump sum, but it’s the cost of actually making good on promise. What are some of the businesses that you, and kind of left-field types of startups, that you would love to see kind of coming in and applying to the program?

Alan Tsen
Yeah, so I mean, we’ve unfortunately now closed applications as we do this podcast, but always willing to have a chat to startups. We’re always recruiting, and specifically we’ll be recruiting again for next season, so please do reach out, nonetheless, in spite of the fact that we’ve closed applications. But we have a number of verticals that we have been looking at. It’s worth sort of maybe conceptualising the types of innovation we’re thinking about, right? It’s not just insurtech, and I think that’s what usually happens with programs like ours, is people think, oh, it’s a direct insurtech play that we’re looking at. It’s actually generally not.

We’re looking for things that are going to either move the strategy forward for the business or are going to future-proof the business. And from perspective, we can, it, we looked at across spectrum: data, AI, ML. We’ve looked at computer vision startups, we’ve looked at startups in the CDR space, right? And so a range of startups that potentially could have an insurance use case, and we thought really, to be honest, quite laterally about that. So when we announced the startups, I think you’ll see that a lot of them aren’t what you would necessarily think, similar to what you were just saying about Aaska. That’s the type of thing that you tend to think like, oh, how does that fit, interest… Oh, okay, that’s interesting use case for the insurance sector. So yeah, that’s how we’ve tended to think about.

Dexter Cousins
And some of the most, I think, interesting applications that I’ve seen of blockchain so far have been within the insurance space as well, thinking specifically R3, parametric insurance, some really kind of interesting use cases there. Is that something that you kind of see as well? Or is it, you kind of, you looking at, rather than kind of trying to redefine or make insurance sexy, which I think, earlier when I was involved in insurtech, was something I just shake my head out. This, I don’t think you’re ever going to make insurance sexy, but there are some really kind of cool things that I think you can do with emerging technology that are going to push the boundaries. What are you kind of seeing as the things that have got you excited right now?

Alan Tsen
Yeah, so personally in insurance space, I think there are so many different interesting vectors that startups can take to enter directly the sector, or the opportunity to actually augment insurers with new and interesting technologies. Sort of two bucket that I get excited about. So I think on the direct entry into insurance space, so many different vectors. I think one that’s really hot at the moment is embedded insurance. So we’ve tended to see that at the point of sale.

Dexter Cousins
Yeah.

Alan Tsen
But so many different vectors, so many different segments as well that are big opportunities. I jump well outside of things that maybe listeners have sort of seen, but hinki, which is a sort of a specialty watch blog, they started offering insurance, and it was just a really interesting sort of play for that type of business. That’s a blog that focuses on what’s happening in luxury watches, to start to offer insurance product.

Dexter Cousins
Yeah.

Alan Tsen
Again, just it fits with the journey of the customer, as they learn, they buy, and then they think through, oh well, insurance is an important element of this as well. If I’ve got a $50,000 watch, or $10,000, whatever that number is, right? And so just an interesting example.

And then I think on the enabler side, so many different technologies we sort of see. Obviously climate is an issue in the insurance sector. That’s a space that I think many insurers would be looking at globally. Again, this whole range of things that are happening obviously in ML and AI at the moment that are super interesting. They have applications in insurance. So I think those are two broad buckets: sort of direct competitors, but then also I really love that enabler space.

Dexter Cousins
Yeah. You’ve been around the ecosystem since day one, Alan. What are your thoughts around kind of how we bring everything together and start to look at new applications of emerging technologies?

Alan Tsen
Yeah, I think it’s probably natural that things start to niche out. When I got into fintech, it was basically lending and payments. That was, right…

Dexter Cousins
Peer-to-peer lending we had, right? Kind of started the process off with, I think, the first kind of application going into the regulators.

Alan Tsen
Yeah, yeah. And then payments, right? And they were very much sort of classic PSP-style businesses. And we’ve come so far, right? And the thing there is to just, this specialisation that comes with the sector really opening up is what we’ve tended to see, right? So in some ways what we’ve seen with buy now pay later is sort of an application of how payments can be done, combined with a lending overlay, right? And so you start to see these interesting use cases develop, where they’re more specific, they’re more tailored, they hit a specific segment or niche or market. And that’s just the evolution of the segment, sorry, the sector, here in Australia and in global, right?

And so now the question comes, and I think it’s a common question, is like, what does the consolidation piece look like, right? So a little bit, yeah, unclear where that plays out, but that’s sort of what I think is going to happen, versus necessarily this full circle moment where things come back around in new applications, sorry, current applications flip into new applications. I think we probably just see bit of consolidation.

Dexter Cousins
That sort of circle back. Now, I talked about events in 2013 kind of being the beginning, but I was actually wrong, and why I’m wrong is that Tyro this month celebrates their 20th birthday.

Alan Tsen
It’s wild.

Dexter Cousins
Crazy. You kind of, I guess, the OG of Aussie fintech. 20 years ago they were started, and Andrew Rothwell, if you’re listening, mate, congrats to you and Paul and Peter on, I guess, carving the way really for what has turned into an industry in itself. But it’s amazing when you think, they kind of, it wasn’t probably until 2018, early 2019, that you really felt the kind of momentum building to this then becoming a standalone industry. What have been your kind of thoughts on, I guess, what won that journey of Tyro, and then kind of what the future holds for the industry here in Oz?

Alan Tsen
Yeah, firstly congrats to the team, everyone that’s contributed to the success of Tyro. Are listed now. Much humble at beginnings. I’m sure the team would also say that, but a great success story, so congrats to them. It’s indicative of sort of the space, right? We’re just talking about some of the segments that were around handful of years ago, payments being one, and it continues to be an important part of what fintech is. So there’s almost a story here around the tried and true challenges that businesses and individuals face is still relatively similar around payments, and that story continues.

But the industry’s grown so much since then. Every so often, when we chat, Dexter, or any of the OGs in the fintech space, about the first meetups, or when we started FinTech Australia, the faces that were in the room, and how few startups there were, and what the issues were, and what the challenges were, they’ve evolved so much, and so much growth has happened. So yeah, it’s just interesting to hear, when you put it in the context of a startup being around for 20 years, that’s pretty amazing. And they’d probably not call themselves a startup anymore, but great story.

Dexter Cousins
Tier One People turned seven this year, just same month actually as FinTech Australia will turn seven as well. And I can’t believe where seven years has gone, right?

Alan Tsen
Didn’t even think about it. Seven years is a long…

Dexter Cousins
Yeah.

Alan Tsen
That’s a long time for an organisation as well. So yeah, well, congrats to you, Dexter. Great seven years.

Dexter Cousins
Yeah, many more to come. Now, Fintech Radar. What are people missing if they’re not a subscriber? Because, like, I get so many emails, right? And this is one that I absolutely take the time to read as soon as it hits my inbox.

Alan Tsen
Yeah, thanks for the plug, Dex. I’ll send the money later. It’s my little newsletter. I write a newsletter weekly. I’ve come back onto the keyboard after taking a little bit of time off. Got, as with most things, busy with life, but have come back. And the premise is simple. It’s just my insights into what I think is interesting in the world of fintech, and I don’t pull any punches. I have fairly strong views, generally loosely held. I’m happy to have them challenged, and for people to comment about what I think about the industry.

But that’s the premise, is I look at a few different funding rounds every week, and then some key pieces of news that have caught my attention, and then I like to drop in some odds and ends from the industry that have either made me laugh or made me think, or maybe some instances made me cry. But always trying to just provide interesting information about what’s happening in the world of fintech, with my maybe unique lens on it. So yeah, that’s Fintech Radar in N.

Dexter Cousins
Cool. What prompted you to start the newsletter?

Alan Tsen
Yeah, I’ve always found writing to be a great way to stimulate my thinking. So I wanted to put pen to paper and really think about some of the issues that were going on in the industry and some of the pieces of news, to really challenge my thinking and just sort of make me think about what are some of the meta trends that are happening that sit behind a fundraise, or a new startup announcing a product, or whatever it might be. So for me it was really a tool for thought, and it still continues to be, to be quite frank.

When I start writing every week, I generally don’t know what I’m going to write about. I sort of see a piece of news: oh, that’s interesting, I wonder why, right? And so for example, last week was just lamenting a fundraise in North Africa, and I’d sort of looked at North Africa in my previous role and thought a little bit about it with the rest of the expansion team. And fascinating segment, fascinating space, and so much growth still to come in North Africa, and probably actually misunderstood as to the opportunity. So P paper, wrote about it, right? And so yeah, always something interesting happening in the world F.

Dexter Cousins
Yeah. We talked earlier about some of the challenges that the industry faces, and particularly those that are losing their jobs. And one thing that I’ve encouraged people to do, certainly over this last, I’d say kind of even decade, has been to, I would say, emulate what you’re doing in your career, which is really to create a profile and be known for having expertise and an opinion in a certain space or a niche. What are the tips that you’ve got for people who kind of maybe thinking about what’s next in their career, about some of the steps that they can take, versus just doing the resume and kind of applying on job boards? Because I think that’s going to be a really difficult thing to do in the current climate.

Alan Tsen
Yeah, and I think it’s hard to stand out with just that. Like, that’s just, I think, a fact, right? And so I think that the advice that I give to definitely people that are new to the industry is that really getting involved is important, right? And actually putting yourself out there and adding value to the ecosystem is incredibly important. And that’s sort of my story, right? Like, I started out helping with meetups here in Victoria, right, and working with the ecosystem and just trying to be helpful with the expertise I had. And then from there, just always being someone that was willing to put their hand up and assist, and that’s how I got involved with Australia, right? Was willing to get out there and sort of assist in any way I could.

So I think one is just being in the mix is really important, and putting yourself out there, adding value. And then to the extent that writing a newsletter or doing a podcast, whatever it might be, that gets yourself out there, your brand out there, is important. I think really being known for having an opinion about things is valuable, right? Because then that tends to attract the people that want to know more about that, and potentially then with it opportunities. So 100% concur with those comments, Dexter. Those are some of the pieces that I’ve always strived to do through my career, and continue to do that.

It also helps that I really love it, right? I genuinely love it. So I think that’s the other important piece here, is finding that joy in it, right?

Dexter Cousins
And this is the thing I tried to get across to people, as we kind of talk about, oh, I’ve got to find something passionate about. When I start my business, I wasn’t passionate about fintech. I just sensed there might be an opportunity. I’ve become passionate about it because, like you, I’ve immersed myself in the world, I’ve tried to be helpful and create value. I genuinely care about the people. I genuinely see the kind of bigger picture as well, which is that what fintech actually represents to Australia as an opportunity, as a nation, and to be part of that is the thing that kind of keeps me going.

Alan Tsen
Totally, totally. And I think just the core of it is putting yourself out there, engaging, and again, I just can’t emphasise enough, just adding value, right? Don’t be a dick, I think, is, I mean, I think that’s just a rule to live by.

Dexter Cousins
But yeah, definitely. Yeah, don’t be a dick. Now, Alan, it’s been great to have you on the show. Where can people subscribe to Fintech Radar?

Alan Tsen
Yeah, so if you want to subscribe, it’s a Substack, so fintechradar.substack.com. On Twitter, if you want to see some of my takes there as well, I’m just alantsen on Twitter.

Dexter Cousins
Awesome. And FMX, where can people apply for the accelerator program?

Alan Tsen
Yeah, so if you want to know more about FMX, jump online. You can find us at fmx doyar collective.com. You’ll get all the information you need about the program. By all means, just reach out to me. I’m happy to have a chat. Easy to find online, so yeah, you’ll easily be able to reach me.

Dexter Cousins
One last question. What’s the podcast that you’re listening to at the minute?

Alan Tsen
What am I listening to at the moment? I listen to a lot of NBA podcasts at the moment. The season’s on, so I’m listening to a lot there. And then sort of the classic fintech ones, obviously, Fintech Chatter, and then Fintech Insider.

Dexter Cousins
Yeah, 11:FS. Yeah, 11:FS. David’s actually going to be on the show in couple of weeks, so if you’ve got any questions, folks, send them in and I’ll ask them of David. Alan, great to catch up. Let’s not make a three years for the next one.

Alan Tsen
No, definitely. Let’s catch up way sooner, on the podcast and in person.

Dexter Cousins
Awesome. And you can follow me, Dexter Cousins, on LinkedIn and Twitter. If you’re new to the show, make sure to follow us and leave a review, and if you’re coming back, thanks so much for your support. Until the next episode, stay safe.

← All episodes

More like this

Related episodes.

Looking to scale your fintech?

Talk to Tier One People ↗