Podcast
Blockchain News – May 2023.
Welcome to the May edition of Blockchain News with Dexter Cousins and Chloe White.
Chloe dials in from Croatia and shares some of the projects she’s been working on across CBDC’s, Digital Assets and Tokenisation.
Dexter and Chloe discuss:
03:00 – The role AI plays in Blockchain
11:00 – Regulation for Blockchain and AI
14:30 – Hong Kong is a Crypto friendly Hub – fact or fiction?
16:45 – The banking collapse and De-Dollarization
26:00 – Tokenisation and Fractional investing
Blockchain News Headlines
https://www.bbc.com/news/world-us-canada-65452940
https://cointelegraph.com/news/circle-ceo-warns-of-active-and-accelerating-de-dollarization
https://cryptonews.com/news/visa-to-develop-brazilian-blockchain-powered-cbdc-project.htm
https://cointelegraph.com/news/hong-kong-s-crypto-rules-set-a-high-bar-for-good-reason-says-sfc-advisor
https://www.blockchaintechnology-news.com/2023/04/cofund-tokenises-luxury-bali-hotel-using-tokeny/
About Chloe White
Chloe was Australia’s inaugural National Blockchain Roadmap Lead and former advisor to the Australian Government on crypto-asset innovation. She is now playing a key role in policy development and regulation globally through her advisory business, Genesis Block.
Connect with Chloe on Linkedin
What happened next.
This episode was published in May 2023, with Chloe dialling in from Croatia to discuss her work on CBDCs, digital assets and tokenisation, along with regulation for blockchain and AI.
Chloe and Dexter recorded one more Blockchain News, published in June 2023 as the last of the series. Chloe argued that the most realistic path for Australia resembled the European Union’s approach, built with academics and researchers as trusted voices. She also reported that the Commonwealth Bank, which had been participating in the RBA’s CBDC pilots, estimated that its smart contract payment-splitting pilot could save Australia $1.5 billion a year in fraud and administration if implemented at scale.
- Is it game over for blockchain? Chloe White (2023), with the full transcript
- Blockchain Chatter episode 001 with Chloe White (2022)
- All Fintech Chatter episodes
Links from this episode.
- Genesis Block, Chloe’s advisory business
- Chloe White on LinkedIn
- Dubai Virtual Assets Regulatory Authority (VARA), the licensing regime Chloe discusses
- Circle CEO Jeremy Allaire on de-dollarisation at Consensus 2023
- Mark Carney’s 2019 Jackson Hole speech, the Bank of England speech Chloe recommends
- BrickX, the Australian fractional property platform Dexter mentions
- Tier One People
Chloe White on Fintech Chatter.
- Is it game over for blockchain? Chloe White (2023), the last Blockchain News, with the full transcript
- Blockchain Chatter episode 001 with Chloe White (2022), recorded the week after the collapse of FTX
- Blockchain News live from Singapore Fintech Festival (2022)
- Blockchain News with Chloe White (2022), on the RBA’s CBDC work and the Ethereum merge
- Chloe White on Genesis Block (2022), episode 111, on building an advisory business
- All Fintech Chatter episodes
Full transcript.
Lightly edited for readability — filler words removed, wording otherwise unchanged.
Dexter Cousins
Welcome to Blockchain Chatter News, your monthly roundup and dissection of interesting news headlines and developments across blockchain and digital assets. I’m your host Dexter Cousins, and my co-host as always is Chloe White. Chloe was Australia’s inaugural National Blockchain Roadmap Lead and former adviser to the Australian Government on crypto asset innovation. She’s now playing a key role in policy development and regulation globally through her advisory business, Genesis Block.
Chloe joins me today from Croatia to discuss the latest blockchain and digital asset developments and share her insights on what is happening across the globe. Chloe, great to see you again, and welcome back.
Chloe White
Thanks Dexter, lovely to see you.
Dexter Cousins
I think last time we caught up you were in the Middle East. Could you mind tell us a bit about what you’ve been up to since we last caught up?
Chloe White
That’s right. Last time we caught up we talked about the launch of the virtual asset licensing regime in Dubai, and I’m now in Europe for the third time this year. It’s been a great year so far, hasn’t it? I’m in Croatia at an academic conference talking about stablecoins and CBDCs, and I also had an opportunity recently to guest lecture for Cambridge University. They have an executive education course on virtual assets, and so I spoke to an audience of regulators about policy principles there, and that was really interesting and I enjoyed being a part of that.
The other thing I’ve been up to is, and this is off the back of the launch of the licensing regime in Dubai, is talking to lots of different businesses who have an interest in obtaining licences in Dubai. So yeah, there’s a lot of activity happening in the policy space, but I think we’re certainly seeing a lot of debate and discussion across blockchain, virtual assets in political and policy circles at the moment. So it’s nice to also be working on some constructive, progressive projects in Dubai and in other places around the world too.
Dexter Cousins
Yeah, awesome. Now, it’s been probably a crazy couple of months since we last caught up. We’ll talk about this a little bit later around what we’ve seen in the banking system, but the other thing that’s happened, and I don’t know if you’ve noticed this as well, but obviously the AI has gone crazy. Mainstream attention is being paid to it, but it almost seems to have been hijacked by the crypto community. What’s your kind of sense on AI and the role that it plays within digital assets?
Chloe White
I think people in the virtual asset industry are very excited about programmability and automation, and so it’s very obvious why people in the blockchain space are really interested in AI at the moment, because we’ve started to see the fruition of many years of work in AI models, where we have things like ChatGPT and Auto-GPT that are getting a lot of attention in tech circles. And the mainstream is aware of these and is starting to play with them as well. And one thing I’ve observed is that those conversations have transitioned from nerdy tech circles into mainstream very, very quickly.
There’s, I think, an easier penetration and grokking of the concepts as some of these models. And I think that looking at emerging technologies as a whole, AI has probably done the best job of all of the emerging technologies in telling its story, selling itself as, we can help find breakthroughs in treatments for cancer, and all of these things that everybody understands why they’re value adding and important straight away. It doesn’t rely on esoteric concepts or advanced economic concepts or financial engineering, all these other things where it’s not obvious to the everyday person what their value is.
And so coming back to the intersection with virtual assets, I think that what people in the blockchain industry see is that a lot of these AI tools are complementary assets. If you can have AI automation and link that through to your smart contracts or your DAO, or in reverse, if you can use a DAO to govern and own and manage AI assets, you can see how these technologies can complement each other, and the innovation that we’re now seeing come through where people are building on each other’s innovations. So that idea of complementary value where you combine these things has got people quite excited.
And in the blockchain space, I think because of where we are in the market cycle as well, a lot of noise has cleared out of this space. And so in every bear market you observe that you have this core group of people who ultimately they do love the tech and they are tech nerds. They’re tech people in their hearts, and so they get excited because they see, they don’t only love blockchain technology, they love all emerging and innovation technology. So of course naturally they’re very excited to see how they fit into AI and how AI fits into them.
Dexter Cousins
So if I cast my mind back to 2017, a lot of the discussions at the time when I was going to fintech meetups, and at that time you had like 20, 30 people in the room, but the most of the talk was around AI. And certainly towards the end of 2017, crypto, Ethereum, we spend a lot of time talking about smart contracts and blockchain as well. And we’re now six years on, and it’s kind of really struck me as to why is it taking this long for this kind of realisation to come, when the room’s full of innovative kind of people, but also the tech nerds as well.
What do you think is, because it’s really hard for me to kind of detract from the cynical part, which is, hey, the hype cycles that we see, and the kind of to the moon and all of that side to it, to go, hey, well, where are the actual real use cases? And you kind of talk about a lot, which I’ve seen with a number of businesses around health. So if you think through the pandemic that we had, the reason why we were able to as a global community get a kind of treatment for that within 12 months was because of AI. We were able to synthesise that data through AI. Where do you think the real kind of opportunity is, and the actual natural fit for these two worlds to come together into real use cases that are going to kind of advance society?
Chloe White
I was trying to do research on the intersection of AI and virtual assets a few years ago when I was doing the National Blockchain Roadmap, and it was very, very hard to find any information. So I do agree with you that sometimes it does take a bit of time for the narrative to emerge. And when we have these memetic or viral narratives that a large cohort of people can understand and repeat to their neighbour, that’s when I think people start to accept the possibility and want to spend more time and pay attention.
Let me give you an example, one in each direction. So I think the kind of techno-futuristic, maybe dramatic example would be, you’ve got an investment fund on chain that is completely managed by an AI, and no human can interfere or stop it, and the AI does whatever it…
Dexter Cousins
Sign me up. Sign me up now. No fees, right?
Chloe White
Essentially running a business, right? You’ve got an investment fund with no human managers involved. That’s really not very hard to imagine if you think about the fact that we already have some assets on chain that are so decentralised that even the founders, who have said, oh, I wish I could go and change something about this thing I created, but I can’t. And there are assets, it’s like an object floating in space. They just exist on chain now, and there’s nothing anyone can do about it.
And so I think that we could maybe see something emerge where an interim step is, okay, I’m a researcher of investment theories, and I want to set up an investment portfolio according to a particular data set, a backward-looking or forward-looking theory, and I’m going to use this AI tooling. I’m going to get the AI to actually write up the code according to these algorithms, and then the AI is actually going to implement the code and execute the trades and basically do all of the grunt work of setting up and managing the fund. But I, as the financial engineer, will continue to have some human involvement, because I do have a key and I can make changes, and I’m going to sell this as a financial product.
And now, this is again promoting VARA, but you can actually go and get a licence to be that asset manager on chain, because there are a couple of progressive policy makers around the world who will allow this combination of technology to be used in this way. I’m sort of saying, okay, we can actually see how we would get to a place where we had an AI-managed investment fund, but we also can see going in the reverse way.
There are a lot of debates as well that have been raging for years about big tech platforms, and this is a really interesting angle to the AI disc as well, and I think something that people are quite concerned about. And we’ve seen some countries that have banned ChatGPT.
Dexter Cousins
I don’t know if you’ve seen today, so the head of AI at Google’s actually resigned and has kind of gone a flip 180 and is now, we’ve got to stop this, it’s too dangerous. Which, my kind of next question to you was going to be, what we’ve seen in digital asset space and crypto in particular in the last 12 months, the kind of lack of regulation has created some real big, like, disastrous stuff, right? Combining that with AI, which is even less regulated than the digital asset space, seems a kind of fairly volatile. How do you think we get through this, and what do you think the timeline is for governments to actually act? Because it seems to me like it seems to be getting a bit close to being edgy now.
Chloe White
I think governments generally have three options. If they think something is clearly negative, they will ban it. If they think that something has a mix of pros and cons, they will regulate it. But if governments actually don’t know what their interests are, they will do nothing, because they will retain option value and wait and watch and see what other countries do. And so with emerging technology, and this is especially the case in blockchain, but it’s also true for AI, a lot of governments don’t know what their interests are. And there are parts of governments internally, departments that actually have opposing interests or conflicts within the government, and they need to negotiate. And so that can take a very long time and mean that policy responses are delayed.
So in the meantime, you will have some politicians who are incentivised to lobby for a quick and blunt course of action, because nuance takes a really long time, and that’s when you get reactive, knee-jerk policy reactions. So I think that the risk here is, as with blockchain, you throw the baby out with the bath water. You ban things without really exploring what other options there are, and then you lose your first mover advantages, as someone else who’s got a slightly better adjusted risk appetite is able to start to lead in a particular product or innovate in certain area and generate IP that then becomes a strategic asset.
So generally, if you have a healthy relationship between the public and private sectors, where you can actually look at a range of options, you will hopefully get a better policy outcome. I don’t think that the best approach is to ban AI. So there’s no shortcut to doing that nuanced work and actually putting some resources into understanding what are the risks, what are the benefits, and what costs are we willing to bear to reap the rewards of the innovation.
Dexter Cousins
No. I guess one country who’s has probably been forging ahead in the AI space is China, where they’ve really been lagging is in the blockchain space, and probably been the most forceful of all nations, and kind of that thing that you talked about, which is if they don’t want it, they’ll just block it or ban it. But then we’ve seen recently that that started to ease. Hong Kong now is being presented as a place where they’re going to be digital asset friendly. I’ve heard kind of mixed reviews. Some people have been excited, or others have been a bit cautious. What’s your take on Hong Kong as a kind of centre for innovation and digital assets?
Chloe White
People in the industry are certainly talking about Hong Kong, and the news that’s been circulating in the last couple of days around Hong Kong’s support for providing banking services to the crypto industry is really positive. Banking is extremely valuable and something that is an ongoing struggle for the blockchain industry. At the same time, we’ve seen that Hong Kong’s track record has left a lot of people quite wary. They know that China has a huge amount of influence there, and China often likes to ban blockchain-related business models, as you’ve said.
So I don’t see any businesses that are rushing to go and set up in Hong Kong, but they are certainly paying attention. They are talking about it. I think the hope at the moment is that these more progressive jurisdictions like Hong Kong will influence other jurisdictions to want to compete. And so if there’s a critical mass of competition and jurisdictions start to see the benefit of that, then everybody benefits. And so we do, I think, keep a close eye on how things develop in Hong Kong, but at the moment I don’t know anyone who sort of approaching this without a grain of salt, just because of that track record, and I think it does make people a bit nervous.
Dexter Cousins
Yeah. Now, as an economist yourself, and I’m somebody who has a deep interest in certainly global economics and, I guess, the dynamics that we’re seeing teally between China and the US. There’s a really interesting conversation at Consensus last week with Jeremy Allaire, the CEO of Circle, who was really warning of de-dollarisation. And we’ve seen this recent banking crisis, and the All-In podcast talking about hyperinflation and pushing for bank runs and all this crazy stuff that’s been going down.
Where do you see, I guess, the events that have happened recently, and where do you think it kind of pictures the technology for what could be the beginning of essentially a new world order, right? Like, I’m not going to make any kind of predictions around China being the new world order, but it certainly seems like things are changing quite quickly.
Chloe White
I’ve observed that a lot of stablecoin advocates and some CBDC advocates, they like to talk about accelerating dollarisation as an argument in favour of using blockchain to tokenise the US dollar as a way of defending the US’s position. I don’t know if dollarisation is happening as rapidly as Jeremy suggests. There actually have been a lot of trade deals negotiated outside of the US dollar for a long time, but those kinds of deals have been getting more attention recently as people have become more aware.
Dexter Cousins
Yeah, we’ve also, I guess, seen the sanctions with Russia, and kind of through the war as well, which maybe just kind of heightened that awareness.
Chloe White
Yeah, exactly. So I think that this is actually just a bubbling along of a trend that’s actually been established for some time, and it makes sense with the sanctions on Russia that this is continuing. And the world order has been evolving for a couple of decades in this direction, so this is not like a sudden phenomenon. Having said all of that, there are genuine issues to think through when we talk about what is the role of the US dollar in the world economy. How does it benefit the US and the world? What does it cost the US and the world?
The former Bank of England Governor Mark Carney, in his last year of his term as Governor, gave a really interesting speech at Jackson Hole, where central bank governors convene, and he set out in that speech an argument for creating like a central bank digital currency that was like a world currency, a new reserve currency that would replace the US dollar as being the world reserve. And that’s so interesting, because for a sitting Bank of England Governor to kind of set out that argument, I think it’s an interesting voice to send that message. But if you go and find this speech online and read through it, it’s I think really worth reflecting on, because he does a great job of setting out some reasons why this global basket of currencies, if you tokenise it and you have that as a world reserve, that could actually be quite good for global economics.
I think that we also in this conversation need to think about the interplay between central banks and public finance and the private banking sector. And so the argument goes that the traditional banking sector faces a threat from blockchain, and they face a threat from fintech and banks, and so their job is to retain their market power by lobbying for moats around themselves. And what you’ve seen over the last 35 years is that the banking sector has been slowly collapsing. We’ve seen rising compliance costs and new government policies that come in with every crisis situation, and those rising compliance costs cause more consolidation in the industry.
And so the number of US banks 35 years ago was around 16,000, and now there’s less than 5,000. So there’s less than a third of the number of banks left than there was a few decades ago. And that linear trend, where it’s just shrinking and shrinking, there’s no indication that that trend is going to stop at all. So despite the fact that banks have succeeded in blocking out a lot of fintech and neobanks from emerging as real competition, they haven’t been able to actually maintain their own existence very successfully.
And so what are the implications of CBDCs potentially displacing private finance even further than the costs of compliance and regulation are already doing? I think that that’s something that governments and central banks are aware of, but because of the geopolitical overlay that causing competition in the CBDC space, there are so many different considerations here. And we haven’t even talked about implications for consumers. So this is a very, very complicated discussion, and I think that there hasn’t been a very good assessment so far of the cost and benefits to these different stakeholder groups.
Dexter Cousins
Now, kind of going back eight, nine months back with the collapse of Luna, whilst it was not a positive thing in any shape or form, it did to an extent show, and certainly what we’ve seen particularly with Bitcoin, show that the technology works. Maybe the human interaction doesn’t know conversation that we had earlier around the synergies between AI and blockchain technology.
If you look at what we’ve got, three today now with First Republic, I think that’s three bank collapses in the US in the last three months. None of them had to do anything with blockchain or fintech. It had to do with poor treasury management. Now, somebody in my network had put up a post today, and I don’t know if this is true or not, but the value of those three banks combined was actually more than the value of the 35 banks that went down in the GFC in the US. So the point that you’ve been making about this kind of slow collapse of the banking system is we’re seeing more, fewer banks, but they’re actually holding more in deposits, and the treasury management kind of isn’t up to scratch. It poses a real, real risk, right?
Chloe White
That’s the irony of the whole situation, Dexter, is that these regulation get brought in supposedly to reduce risk in the system, and the system keeps consolidating, and then you have these too big to fail banks. And so we’ve had top 20 bank failures in this recent period over the last few months. And so I think that there’s a lot of anger at the moment as well about the inconsistency of how governments have responded to each individual. It feels like they’re picking winners and losers, or people to save and people that they’ll let drown.
And that’s adding to a lot of the suspicion as well around Operation Choke Point 2.0, and I think it’s really adding fuel to the fire about, does the US want to be a facilitative environment for this kind of emerging technology? I think that the conclusion that people have drawn is clearly not. There’s been very little by way of efforts to engage constructively on clarifying regulations. And so I think that we’ve really seen that people now have to make some very difficult decisions about whether they want to continue to try and build in what is not only a difficult economic environment, but a very difficult political environment.
Dexter Cousins
Now, we’ve talked about tokenisation a bit, and particularly with reference to CBDCs, but I wanted to chat with you about another, I guess, concept around tokenisation, which is fractional investment. And particularly, I think there was an article that I sent you around how blockchain technology is been used to co-fund a luxury hotel that’s being built in Bali. This is a concept that’s not new. Kind of go back to BrickX, Aussie fintech that tried to push the concept of fractional investment in Australian property and give people the opportunity to get involved in the property market. Great concept, great idea, but, I guess, the kind of behavioural economics aspect of it didn’t quite get traction. What do you see is kind of being different this time around own by using blockchain technology to kind of, I guess, make work a concept that so far has failed in its execution?
Chloe White
I think that the focus on retail is where a lot of people have kind of missed the mark here. And so there’s actually a real market of B2B assets and investment assets for sophisticated investors, where it’s not supposed to be necessarily a high volume, high turnover, low value retail application of this fractionalisation, tokenisation model. What I’m seeing in my work is that there are businesses who have established asset management services and financial products. They see that the advantage of tokenising those products is to be able to add liquidity to that market. By adding liquidity to that market, they can expand the services they provide.
And so that’s really what’s important about tokenisation. When you fractionalise an asset that in the Web 2 world would be very hard or very expensive to fractionalise and to manage the liquidity of those fractional contracts, now suddenly it becomes economical for you to offer that. And so I recently supported a client in Singapore with this exact concept. They have taken their assets that are only for approved, accredited investors, but they’ve said, well, even if you’re a sophisticated investor, it doesn’t necessarily mean that you want to put huge chunks of money into one single investment opportunity. You may still want to diversify many assets. And so how do we fractionalise and break this down?
And so I think that that kind of institutional finance, B2B opportunities, taking existing business models and adding liquidity to the markets that they manage, that is a much more interesting prospect than, I think, some of these retail pop kinds of applications we talk about, someone like BrickX, buying a very small fraction of real estate. The real estate example is the most common example that we tend to hear about when we hear about tokenisation, and the reason I think that that’s the wrong case study is because when we talk about residential real estate, that’s strictly, it’s not an investment asset in pure terms. It’s a consumable asset, and people make decisions that are not necessarily intended to be financial decisions, even though they implicitly are, but they’re making emotional decisions and lifestyle decisions.
And so it’s probably a little bit of a distraction, and sometimes of clickbait as well, because it resonates with people, because residential real estate is something that people can connect with easily as a story. But I don’t think it’s the best way to understand the benefits of tokenisation.
Dexter Cousins
Now, we’re kind of coming to a wrap, Chloe, but before we do, what’s next for you?
Chloe White
Well, I’m going to be continuing to support companies who are wanting to get licensed in Dubai: tokenisation, asset management, token issuers who are building blockchain native solutions. It’s very exciting. So this is kind of where I’m putting all of my energy at the moment. And continuing as well to do research on stablecoins and to support the stablecoin sub-sector. It’s something that I am just still so fascinated by, and I think is such an obvious use case for this fintech. So that’s kind of me right now. I am really looking forward to the conference this week and meeting other researchers in the space, and then next, well, not even next month, in a couple of weeks I’ll be in Australia catching up.
Dexter Cousins
Welcome home.
Chloe White
Yeah, thanks. So that’ll be my next destination.
Dexter Cousins
Fantastic. Well, Chloe, it’s as always great to catch up. Thanks for sharing your insights, and I look forward to doing this again next month.
Chloe White
Always a pleasure. Thank you, dear.
Dexter Cousins
And you can connect with me, folks, on LinkedIn and Twitter. If you’re coming back, thanks for your support, and if you’re new to the show, make sure to give us a subscribe and like, follow us on your podcast player. Until the next episode, keep well.


