Nell Hardie is Head of Talent for Reinventure Group, the Westpac backed VC fund for Fintech. Nell is ideally placed to give a finger on the pulse of the current hiring market across Fintech.
In the show Nell shares where she is seeing job opportunities across the portfolio. which jobs are most at risk and how founders can retain their teams through covid-19, ready for the recovery as we move out of lockdown.
Welcome To The Tier One People Fintech Jobs Report.
Sydney Advertises Four Hundred Fintech Jobs!
Developers and Engineers make up more than 50% of all jobs advertised in Australia.
On the face of it, the Sydney Fintech jobs market is going gangbusters compared to every other city with almost 400 advertised positions. But when we analysed the data from advertising platforms including Seek, Indeed, Glass Door, LinkedIn, the real story was nowhere near as impressive.
Find out which jobs are in demand, who is doing the hiring and how using recruiters could be doing your business more harm than good.
"There is a lot of uncertainty in the market which is concerning for business leaders. A Royal Commission, open banking, a looming Brexit, a general election, Apple moving into financial services, Libra. All of these things are weighing on executives minds."
Will the fintech platform we are building today be relevant 12 months from now?
Technology and global markets seem to be moving so fast, most executives are struggling to keep pace. Couple that with the changing regulatory landscape and looking further than 12 months into the future is creating indecision. When decisions are finally made, the market has moved on, the goal posts have changed and so the process starts all over again!
Is The Fintech Hiring Market Stalling?
The answer is no if we look at investment numbers. But we are entering a new evolution, Fintech 2.0 and the platform play. The pressure is on for founders and executives to deliver to investors and shareholders. The challenge for scaling Fintechs appears to be plateauing top line growth or even an obsolete product/business model.
Most Fintech to date are apps/features or middle layer software solutions. But with the emergence of 'Super Apps' like Revolut the competition is becoming much tougher. And customers expectations are rising.
When it comes to scaling the business two options are most often considered. Grow geographically (Cover Genius and AfterPay have taken this approach) or pivot domestically. To pivot successfully requires two things; new products and people to drive the sales of new products.
Pivots are not exclusive to scaling startups. We see an increasing demand for Fintech talent from corporations pivoting their own product lines. Some are even reinventing their business models. Some examples include FSI’s, Insurers and Software companies.
Based on our assessment of the market there is significant demand for two profiles from Fintech.
Chief Product Officer/Head of Product.
Founders and business leaders seem to be crying out for commercial product managers with the ability to deliver the killer product. Indeed, the EY/Fintech Australia Census 2019 highights Product/Market Fit as the number one challenge for Fintech.
Product areas appear well stocked with those who can project manage. Strategic and commercial acumen seems to be in short supply, leading to months wasted on product development before a market fit has been established. Business leaders dream of applying Lean Startup Principles. While Product teams seem obsessed with following Agile rather than being Agile.
What is the answer?
2019 has seen an increase in Head of Product and a Chief Product Officer searches at Tier One People. We sourced 75% of shortlisted candidates domestically. 25% were international candidates. However, it is a 50/50 split on domestic and international hires made.
Based on the client feedback, it was felt international candidates demonstrated clearer commercial thinking. Most importantly, talent could point to several examples in which they had taken a product from idea to revenue generation, at scale.
It seems the product management community is acutely aware of the problem. Read this excellent blog post by Adrienne Tan https://brainmates.com.au/product-management/cut-out-product-management/
Sales Director/Head of Partnerships.
Revenue growth is hard to come by and the pressure is beginning to show signs. The sizzle of Fintech has attracted a lot of investment. Indeed 2018 saw an all time record for Fintech investment in Australia. And with the additional investment come higher expectations.
I wrote of this phenomenon three years ago, when SaaS businesses went on huge hiring sprees for business development managers.
We are seeing increased demand for people who can bring in new business. Especially significant corporate partnerships that will make an immediate and long term impact on revenue growth.
B2B sales is complex. Deals can take anywhere from 6 - 18 months. B2B2C deals may not take as long, but with API integration to be factored in, there is a heavy dose of project management required to onboard any new client. Deals are fragile and complex with technology and regulatory roadblocks often leading to months of work being wasted.
The market is reacting with an increasing demand for Partnerships Directors. These are rare people indeed. A Partnerships Director must possess the hustle and entrepreneurial drive of a sales person. But with empathy/relationship building and well developed project management skills. If that wasn’t difficult enough to find, strong product knowledge and hands on operational experience is considered essential to the role.
Tier One People have had success sourcing talent from the UK and US markets which are more accustomed to this model.
Design Thinking For Hiring.
Our clients seem to be experiencing better outcomes by adopting a design thinking approach to hiring. Over the last year we have been working with a small group of trusted clients on a new approach to recruitment. It has been so successful that two clients saved close to $500,000.
If you would like to find out more, get in touch to organise a consultation.
Australia's Open Banking Reforms
When Will Australia's Open Banking Revolution Begin?
With Open Banking reforms set for July 2019 we have seen the launch two new Digital Banks in Australia, 86 400 and UP Bank. Cuscal backed 86 400 has serious funding and weight behind it with Anthony Thomson, founder of Atom Bank in the UK, as Chair for the bank.
86 400 is still to receive a full banking license and hopes to launch it's first products early next year. The executive team is in place, in execution mode and there is significant hiring behind the scenes.
UP, backed by Bendigo Bank has quietly entered the market place with prepaid card offering. The UX is super slick with an account set up in minutes via the app. The card is beautifully designed and the app itself let's you track your spending on the card. It is an encouraging start.
Judo Capital announced the second-largest fundraising round in Australian start-up history and expects their full banking license by the end of 2018.
Xinja meanwhile recently held their first AGM and announced series C capital raise valuing the business at AUS $95m. With regulators yet to grant Xinja a restricted banking license the raise is conditional on securing a license.
We are hearing that Neo Banks are turning capital away, significant amounts. Australian consumers and investors are raring to go.
Volt Bank, the only licensed Neo Bank in Australia is quietly going about their business. There is significant hiring with the business now over 70 people strong. Most hiring is on the development side but as yet, the mobile app has not been released. Volt Bank Deputy CEO Luke Bunbury was speaking at Mumbrella recently talking about distrust of banks. And he is 100% on the money.
Everybody wants Neo Banks
Recruiters are having a hard time right now trying to convince top talent to join the big 4 banks. And top talent of the big 4 banks and financial institutions seem eager to move on.
The enquiries are so great in numbers that we are actually having to turn candidates away from large financial institutions. While we would love to help, the career transition from large corporate to startup is difficult with many people failing to make the leap.
And many people in banks offer a very narrow skill set. When you consider CBA has 40,000 staff a Neo Bank will only need 400 staff. So it doesn't look pretty for career bankers, especially the support staff in operations, finance etc.
Despite the high risk involved and the fact that even the licensed Neobanks in Australia are yet to offer a single product, top talent are showing a strong desire to switch.
Peers in the UK are witnessing a similar trend. Contacts at the Global Search firms in London tell me it is a real struggle to fill the top banking jobs. Executives would prefer to join a Fintech where the regulatory sandbox is making life easier, the rewards greater and the opportunity to build and drive change in the industry fulfilling.
What is holding Australia back?
Asian Investment in Fintech has increased significantly in the past 12 months and the UK is 5 years ahead of where Australia is now. Despite the efforts of UP, Judo, Xinja, Volt, 86400, Alex and Douugh, Australians have the choice of one product, a prepaid card. In contrast, ANT Financial in China has a 30 day Go To Market turnaround for new products. It raised US $14bn earlier this year.
Who is to blame for the lack of progress?
The Royal Commission appears to be making life for new entrants super tough and the stance of regulators is clearly stunting innovation and progress. While third world countries advance at a rapid rate, it appears the only ship not rising with the tide is Australia.
Australian Prime Minister Hon Scott Morrison MP gave an impressive and encouraging speech at the Annual Fintech Awards dinner in Sydney recently. He made it explicitly clear the Open Banking programme is a priority with the Government relying on the Fintech industry "not to stuff it up".
If successful, Open Banking will be used as the template for all future Australian innovation. Scott Morrison has put a flag in the sand with Australia's Open Banking initiative set to go live 1st July 2019. He seems personally and politically invested in Open Banking, he can't afford for it to be his NBN!
But July 2019 is only 11 months away!
How much time and energy are we seeing wasted at innovation hubs, conferences and meetups? Are we guilty of confusing motion with progress?
The regulatory sandbox seems to be filled with quicksand. How many Fintech startups are spending time, energy and precious resources pandering to regulators? Waiting months for a response, only to be asked to fill out more forms, answer more questions, when a 30 minute meeting could quickly resolve any minor queries halting progress.
Quietly, small businesses and start up founders are being driven to despair (and often out of business) while corporate, government and regulators appear more interested in perception than progress.
I am convinced Australia has the talent, ideas, capital and capability to be the leading Fintech innovation hub.
So what are the regulators waiting for? Would more progress be made if the spotlight was put on ASIC and APRA?
Mandeep Sodhi - HashChing
Hashching launched in August 2015 as an online marketplace connecting borrowers to a local mortgage brokers. It is a pure Fintech play operating an Uber style model where consumers are connected to a mortgage broker who comes direct to their home.
Dexter Cousins of Tier One People caught up with HashChing CEO, Mandeep Sodhi. He shares a compelling story and the secret sauce to making a Fintech startup a success.
How did the Hashching journey begin?
Mandeep: In August 2014, I decided to buy my first home. As a loyal bank employee, I reached out for the staff discount. At the time, I would boast to my friends about the special discounts I was entitled to as an employee of the bank.
A few days later I found out from a friend that they had secured a better rate from the bank I worked for. How come when they were not entitled to a staff discount and had never even worked for the bank?
I was infuriated, so I reached out to my bank asking how my friend managed to secure a better rate.
The bank simply replied, ‘Because your friend used a mortgage broker.’
Their answer made me even more frustrated, so I started to look at the mortgage broker model in greater detail.
From my research, I could see how much value mortgage advisers were providing their customers. Not only were they saving customers more time by taking away the hassle of completing documentation etc. brokers were securing better rates.
Initially the idea for HashChing, when we joined H2 Ventures in January 2015, was to work with the banks. We approached four of the banks who basically said;
We are happy to work with you guys, but our advisers are only available from Monday to Friday during operating hours only. We do not call clients on Saturday and Sunday or nights.
Consumers need the convenience of a broker coming to their house on the weekend. So, we quickly pivoted the model to service mortgage brokers. More than 50 percent of loans are written by mortgage brokers so we had a huge market to target.
HashChing went live August 2015 with nine brokers. The platform has 586 mortgage brokers across Australia. Each borrower rates a broker based on the service they receive. Any broker who receives less than a 4-star rating is expelled from the platform. Brokers understand.
The brokers have strict KPI's and must call customers within 12 hours of an enquiry even on a Saturday or Sunday. Today an Uber driver can turn up to your house for a ten-dollar ride within five minutes. Borrowers can be making a million-dollar decision, they expect a first-class experience.
Listen to Mandeep talk about his latest venture on the FinTech Australia Podcast
How many people were part of the initial Hashching journey?
Mandeep: Year one, just two confounders, Atul Narang and myself. I was responsible for the broker/customer support and CEO, Atul CTO. The reason for keeping the business so lean was to understand firsthand the customer’s needs.
The approach helped in building the right product first. After year one we expanded our team from two to five people and now we are ten full time staff and one part time. It is a lean business even though we're growing fast. As a tech business, you don’t need an army of people. We are not a call center selling home loans.
HashChing is a technology business with bank level security in place. Brokers use the HashChing dashboard to collect bank statements, loan documents etc. to be lodged to the lender. The information consumers provide to us is completely secured and protected, even our staff cannot access the information. All information is encrypted, we have to make sure we hire the right technology people.
What skills do you look for when growing a tech business?
Mandeep: I was lucky to have a Tech co-founder. As Hashching has grown we've hired a CTO from a big four bank. It is their job to make sure we continue to keep taking security to the next level. And hiring a Senior Architect from a Telco has really helped in making the business scalable. We have grown 10x this last year but the team has not grown. It was always the vision to build a technology platform that can scale quickly.
Equally as important as the tech, is the relationship with mortgage brokers. We hired a Chief Operating Officer, Siobhan Hayden, who came from MFAA. We have not spent a single dollar on broker marketing and the reason for that is the trust Siobhan has within the mortgage broker community.
The final piece of the puzzle is marketing. How do we make the consumer aware of HashChing? If you google hashching you will see, we are in the media quite a lot. The PR has been great for brand awareness. That's because we have the right marketing team in place. When I call it a marketing team, it's a team of two people.
What we need in the future are specialist skills in certain areas of the business. People who can help us continue that growth trajectory. When you start scaling you need to grow your team accordingly, otherwise people will burn out. New skill sets need to come into the company as it continues to grow.
How do you attract the right talent?
Mandeep: I realise that top talent do not leave a cushy job at a corporate to have the same experience. We can attract better talent than a bank because we give employees the flexibility to do their job. There are very clear expectations and KPI's from day one. We remove all bureaucracy.
HashChing empowers employees to make decisions and offers an accelerated career path. People who joined Hashching six months ago have already moved up because they are performing well and show passion for the company. This doesn't happen at a corporate.
We have a unique environment with diverse backgrounds. Everyone is treated in the same manner. The intention has never been to hire for diversity, only to hire the best people. They just happen to come from different backgrounds. However, diversity is critical for innovation. When I consider the backgrounds of our people, they reflect our customer base. The team isn’t measured on innovation, it happens naturally. We think like our customers because we are just like them.
How do you keep people motivated?
The environment at HashChing is like coming to work with your cousins. Going to see your cousins is fun. We have a bond with one another, where we can have fun and feel like we are a family. But at the end of the day, we can go home, so you don’t get the arguments like you might with your siblings. Our people love being here.
They're not getting paid top dollar. I know they can get paid a lot more in corporate world. But it is the satisfaction they get from working with a startup, building something special that keeps them motivated and hungry.
Most of the team approached HashChing directly, explaining how passionate they were about the company. Importantly, they understood the nature of a startup. They did not approach us looking for a fantastic salary and work life balance.
The secret sauce is your team
I was on the stage at a conference recently and someone asked me the secret sauce of the company. I thought about it for a while and I realised the secret sauce is your team. It's not the technology or the algorithm. Technology is an enabler. The team makes the vision come to life. And if you have the right team, even if it is a small team you can out play a bank.
HashChing is fortunate to have super smart people who get on with the job and don't need to be managed at all. The team owns the culture. In fact, it was the team who came up with the HashChing values after two years in business. Culture is critical in a startup and if you hire the wrong person it has a huge impact. You need to act swiftly and decisively. We have made a hiring mistake in the past and I regret not acting sooner. But it was a good learning lesson.
What does the future hold for Hashching.
Mandeep: It is a very exciting time for HashChing. We have grown 10x in the last financial year. That level of growth is across revenue, number of mortgage brokers on the platform and number of mortgage applications processed. It's enormous growth.
Our first home loan product has been launched and is being distributed via our mortgage brokers. We designed the product based on the needs of the broker and the consumer. It is a product that provides same day approval. Brokers and consumers are loving it because now they don't have to wait five days for approval.
The team is continually looking for the parts of the home loan journey that are broken. If you compare home loans from the 1990s nothing has changed. We have 1500+ home loan products in the market but they're all the same. The question we ask ourselves everyday ‘How can we give the consumer more choice and help the brokers more easily fulfill a customer’s needs?’
Is the Hashching business model going global?
Mandeep: HashChing is not exclusively for the Australian market. Today, Australia is the biggest market for us and we need to stay focused. But we are looking at other geographies who have a similar home loans model and regulatory framework. Before going into the other markets, we want to make sure that the model is scalable.
The UK, Canadian and New Zealand markets are the countries we will be exploring first. In the geographies where mortgage brokers do not have a significant presence, we will look to operate a direct model launching our own products.
What is the exit point for you and Hashching?
Mandeep: I'm not thinking about exit at this point. I know a lot of investors do not like that answer but I do not want to sell to the banks. There's a reason why we're going with equity crowdfunding and that is to make sure we stay independent of the banks.
A lot of our competitors are backed by financial institutions. Some have openly disclosed their investors, some have not. Two of the big four banks have approached us in the past. We've politely declined their offers. It's just not the right model for us.
Why would a bank want to invest shareholders money in a startup? It stands to reason that they want to influence their own products on our customers. So how can we claim to be independent if there is a conflict of interest?
What we're seeing with the Royal Commission clearly shows you that banks and financial institutions have very different KPI's to HashChing. Our KPI’s are all based around customer satisfaction and we have a very clear review system to measure that. Where as banks and financial institutions base their KPI’s on sales.
What has been your experience dealing with regulators?
Mandeep: The regulators clearly want to work with startups. But they are not clear on how they want to engage. My view is regulators are setting too many boundaries around innovation which makes progress very difficult. Startups are not trying to disrupt the industry they are striving to give more choice and transparency to consumers. To do that, we need to disrupt existing models.
The regulators seem to think startups present a systemic risk. Regulatory bodies need to acknowledge that startups do better job than the major financial institutions in certain areas. We need the support of the regulators.
Yes, regulators must ensure startups do not cross certain limits or mislead the customer. But regulating a startup in the same way as a bank or financial institution is not going to work. We just don't have the resources or funding to compete.
The royal commission has been a real eye opener for ASIC and APRA. They have openly identified that the banks have done some terrible things. Maybe the regulators can now work with the startups and find ways to solve some of the issues the banks are facing? We are happy to show our tools and share our knowledge with the regulators.
Sydney Fintech jobs update
Sydney Fintech Jobs
At Tier One People, we get to work with some amazing startups in Fintech. January has got off to a flier, so here is the first Tier One People Sydney FinTech jobs update of 2018.
There is an air of optimism that Fintechs will be a success. But the two challenges facing every FinTech and InsurTech? Funding and hiring great people.
The funding issue may no longer be an issue. Last week saw Australia's first ever crowdfunding equity raise. The raising for Xinja (Australia's first NeoBank) was carried out by Equitise. AUS$500,000 was raised in one day and everyday Australians (like me) have been given the opportunity to be an early stage investor in what promises to be a super exciting venture.
Congratulations to Eric Wilson and Van Le of Xinja and Chris Gilbert of Equitise.
Where are all the talented people?
Last month I had meetings with CEOs, CROs, CMOs, CTOs, CFOs and COOs. Each of them described similar people challenges - namely, hiring people who can get results in a VUCA environment with limited resources.
Interestingly only CTOs mentioned technical skills as their biggest problem (even then they can outsource). As one CEO put it, 'I need people who are prepared to work seven days and can get sh!t done.'
It is clear that the education system and corporate structures are failing to prepare people for the new demands of the startup/high growth business model.
If you are serious about a career in Fintech, then you need to master the art of 'getting sh!t done'. Despite what you read in the press, startups are not all about free yoga, beanbags and as much alcohol as you can drink.
Thinking about a move to Fintech? Tier One People are running a free event in February for those looking to make the switch. Contact dexter@tieronepeople.com for details.
In-demand talent of 2018
Finance
There has been a push recently to hire Financial Controllers and CFO's within the Fintech space. With companies growing to enterprise level in record time (Uber started in 2009 and is now valued at $70bn), startups are recognising the need to invest in enterprise-ready infrastructure and finance functions.
Several of the mandates I have received in the past few months have been with companies less than two years old.
Risk
A big year for risk in 2018. Valuations Actuaries, Cyber Security and Regulatory Compliance people in hot demand.
Tech
No change here.
Full stack developers - Yaaaawwn.
Machine learning, Data Science and Analytics still in huge demand.
Blockchain - Expect to see a raft of specialist recruiters in Blockchain.
C Suite
The interim C Suite market is going strong. Have you ever considered utilising CXO services on a 'pay as you go' plan for instance?
If you are looking to grow your Fintech and need specific expertise, for events such as an IPO, acquisition or rapid growth, hiring the person you need is cost prohibitive. Tier One People connect Gig Execs to our Fintech and Insurtech clients. A Gig Exec is a highly experienced executive with specialist experience for specific business events. Readily available for short-term assignments, this is a highly cost-effective solution for FinTech founders requiring executive level support.
Sales
It turns out that making revenue from SaaS and platform solutions is rather difficult, especially if you are relying solely on PR and a digital sales strategy. Tier One People are seeing an increase in demand for Sales Directors and Business Development Managers.
Interestingly the ideal candidate is someone with broad experience in product, distribution and sales. Relationship building and strategic selling are an absolute must. Certainly no used car salesman! It seems the mantra 'People buy people' is truer than ever.
Finding great FinTech people is hard
A great initiative by Cameron Dart and Australian FinTech Jobs, a specialist jobs board for Fintech positions. We have used the platform for several positions and the quality and relevance of candidates gets high ratings from Tier One People.
We always say to our clients hire yourself if you can and when you can't come to us.
Australian FinTech Jobs is generating better results for Tier One People than SEEK (and is a lot cheaper too.) If you are planning to hire direct, I recommend giving the platform a go.
Manage Cookie Consent
We use cookies to optimize our website and our service.
Functional
Always active
The technical storage or access is strictly necessary for the legitimate purpose of enabling the use of a specific service explicitly requested by the subscriber or user, or for the sole purpose of carrying out the transmission of a communication over an electronic communications network.
Preferences
The technical storage or access is necessary for the legitimate purpose of storing preferences that are not requested by the subscriber or user.
Statistics
The technical storage or access that is used exclusively for statistical purposes.The technical storage or access that is used exclusively for anonymous statistical purposes. Without a subpoena, voluntary compliance on the part of your Internet Service Provider, or additional records from a third party, information stored or retrieved for this purpose alone cannot usually be used to identify you.
Marketing
The technical storage or access is required to create user profiles to send advertising, or to track the user on a website or across several websites for similar marketing purposes.