Podcast
Starkware | David Engel.
In episode 002 of Blockchain Chatter, Dexter Cousins is joined by David Engel, Head of Business Development for Starkware, a Layer 2 scaling solution that helps companies build on top of Ethereum while reducing the cost of doing so by up to 1000x.
About David Engel
David is a business development executive, with deep experience in accelerating the growth of Web3 and Fintech companies.
Prior to StarkWare, David was a Fintech BDM at AWS, in both the ANZ and EMEA markets from 2019-2022.
David has also been a Commercial Director for the Australian and New Zealand markets for Verrency, a fintech platform that allows card issuers to innovate faster, and at scale, as well as Australian Country Manager for i2c, a Silicon Valley-based cloud payments processor.
About Starkware
StarkWare is paving the way to a Web3 future, using uncheatable cryptographic technology to scale blockchain for mass adoption.
StarkEx, StarkWare’s SaaS-based scaling service, has settled over $770B, processed over 294M transactions, minted more than 90M NFTs, and serves hundreds of thousands of users monthly through customers like ImmutableX, dYdX and Sorare.
StarkNet, a permissionless, general-purpose scaling solution, is live (Alpha) on Ethereum Mainnet. Developers from across the world are using it to build tomorrow’s decentralized applications.
Links from this episode.
- StarkWare
- StarkEx, StarkWare’s SaaS scaling platform
- StarkNet, the permissionless layer two network
- Cairo, the programming language David mentions
- Immutable
- dYdX
- Sorare
- Canvas
More on blockchain on Fintech Chatter.
- David Lavecky on Canvas (2023), the StarkEx customer David mentions
- Ryan McCall on Zerocap (2023)
- Shane Verner on Fireblocks (2023)
- Brian Collins of Startupbootcamp (2022), the conversation Dexter refers to
- All Fintech Chatter episodes
Full transcript.
Lightly edited for readability — filler words removed, wording otherwise unchanged.
Dexter Cousins
Blockchain Chatter, brought to you by Tier One People, leaders in fintech executive search.
Welcome to Blockchain Chatter, the show where blockchain leaders join me for a chat. I’m your host Dexter Cousins, and today’s guest is David Engel of StarkWare. StarkWare is a layer two scaling solution that helps companies build on top of Ethereum while massively reducing costs and gas fees. David previously covered fintech markets in Europe, Middle East and Africa for AWS, but he’s really well known to the Aussie fintech scene for his time as fintech BDM for AWS and his commercial director at VY. I’m delighted to welcome David, who’s making his long overdue debut on the podcast. David, my friend, so good to see you. How are you?
David Engel
Likewise, sir. It’s a pleasure to be able to connect again.
Dexter Cousins
I cannot believe it has taken… This podcast is three years old now, and this is you making your debut. I can’t believe it. How was it been this long?
David Engel
I was just waiting for you to hit your stride, Dexter.
Dexter Cousins
Well, look, it’s kind of, we’re now at the level where we can book guests like yourself, David, so it’s awesome to have you on now. I’ve been kind of, I think, hassling you probably for the last 12 months. When I found out that you’re going to be moving to Israel, I was like, oh, this could make a really great podcast. And then you move to StarkWare and I like, you’ve got to come on the podcast now. So it’s great to have you with us. But before we kind of talk about StarkWare, do you want maybe just want to share with the listeners a little bit about yourself and who you are?
David Engel
Sure. So as you said, I was at AWS before this. I’ll probably start a little bit before that. So I’m originally American. Moved to Australia in 2004, as I just found out, about two weeks before you made your big move to Australia as well. Was there for the last 18 years. Worked in banking for a while, spent most of my time at GE Capital in managing products and portfolio, so that was more of a credit card business. Then jump from there into startups. I work for a range of different startups, kind of found myself more and more interested in tech. Just enjoyed the pace and the innovation and the quality of the people, especially in Australia. As you would know, and as you contributed to, the fintech scene in Australia is outstanding.
Eventually found my way to AWS to manage the fintech business for Australia, New Zealand. And then nine months ago, almost to the day, picked up my whole family, my wife, my two kids and my dog, and we made the move from Australia back to Israel, which is actually where I met my wife in 1998, and we’ve been here since then.
Dexter Cousins
Awesome. And how’s the family settling into Israel?
David Engel
My family is amazing. The most inspirational part of moving here is seeing my kids, who do not speak Hebrew, jump straight in with both feet. We stuck them both in public school, so they’re literally sitting there learning complex topics in a language they don’t understand, and never had a single complaint. I really find my kids, in the way that they’ve handled the move, inspirational.
Dexter Cousins
Sounds like the dad gone down the Web three rabbit hole.
David Engel
I’ll tell you what, my son is neck deep in physics and coding in Python and robotics.
Dexter Cousins
Oh wow.
David Engel
So I really think he’s just angling for a job in StarkWare in about five to 10 years.
Dexter Cousins
Yeah.
David Engel
Well, my daughter’s angling to be our social media manager, so we’ll see. Another three years and she can legally work for the business.
Dexter Cousins
There you go. There you go. That’s the time that we’re going to see the J curve really take off.
David Engel
That’s it. Yeah, absolutely. We’ll be TikToking everywhere.
Dexter Cousins
I’m so excited to talk you about StarkWare, because the little bits that you shared with me, like some of the numbers, the businesses that you work with, are kind of ma Geor just Dro. But before we go into that, do you want to maybe share with the listeners a little bit about StarkWare and what you guys are about?
David Engel
Sure, happy to. So StarkWare is a layer two scaling solution, and so what that means is we solve the problem of scalability on Ethereum. So I’m sure your listeners will be very familiar with Ethereum, would understand that it is the largest smart contract platform in the world. So what Ethereum does very, very well is allow users to build any kind of program or application that they want on the decentralised internet, on Web 3, and they do that in Solidity on Ethereum. So Ethereum does very well to be able to build any kind of smart contract you want, any kind of program you want, whether that’s DeFi or identity or gaming.
What Ethereum doesn’t do well is scale. So Ethereum is very decentralised. It has many, many nodes or databases all over the world, about 7,000, but it’s hard to scale. So the challenge, as we saw 2021, is that when somebody wanted to do a transaction on Ethereum and the network was very congested, it cost up to $21 to send a single transaction. So which is fine if I’m buying a CryptoPunk NFT for a few hundred thousand dollars. I don’t mind spending $21. But if I want to send Dexter $5 for the coffee yesterday, or if I want to go and pay a merchant in crypto, if it cost me $21 to do that transaction, you literally cannot do it. And so Ethereum cannot scale to the extent that it needs to, to really become the global blockchain network.
So what StarkWare does is StarkWare solves the Ethereum scalability problem through what’s called zero knowledge proofs, and happy to get into that a little bit, and what our customers are building and the results that we’re seeing.
Dexter Cousins
Awesome. Now, you kind of talked through some of the numbers with me, just to give some idea of scale as to the StarkWare platform. Can you share with our listeners this number and repeat it, cuz it’s kind of a bit of a big number?
David Engel
Sure, sure. So what we do is we solve, as I said, the scalability problem on Ethereum, and we’re doing that already in production, as you said, at massive, massive scale. So there might be a few numbers that you’re referring to. The first one is that we have now settled $780 billion onto…
Dexter Cousins
Stop there, stop there, stop there. Say that number again.
David Engel
$780 billion onto the Ethereum network.
Dexter Cousins
Billion with a B, not an M, right? Three quarters of a trillion.
David Engel
That’s right. So three quarters of a trillion dollars we’ve settled on to the Ethereum network. We do that through customers, and we’ll talk more about this, through like dYdX and Immutable and Sorare. But this is scalability. This is exactly what we’re talking about when we say we sell scalability.
Another number that I think will be helpful to listeners, just to give a bit of context. The week of October 10th, Immutable, who’s a great Australian Web 3 company, they’re an NFT marketplace, gaming platform, they did a mint of 10 million NFTs, which again is a substantial number of NFTs. They did that all in a weekend on StarkEx, on our SaaS platform. But what’s really interesting about that number is that in that week StarkWare did 12 and a half million transactions onto Ethereum. Ethereum in total only did 7 and a half million transactions. So we actually did more transactions than Ethereum, 1.6 times as many. We settled all of those transactions on Ethereum, so you have a proof that all those transactions happened on Ethereum.
Here’s the mind-blowing number. Those 12 and a half million transactions took up less than 0.1% of the block space on Ethereum. So when we talk about how do you scale Ethereum to be able to do the next global social media network, the next global credit, the next global card scheme, decentralised identity on a global scale, layer two scaling solutions are the way that you do it, where you can do more transactions, orders of magnitude more transactions on Ethereum, and when you settle them onto Ethereum it takes up less than 0.1% of the overall block space.
Dexter Cousins
Wow. Now, there’s obviously been some issues with some other L2 solutions around security. How have you overcome that challenge?
David Engel
Sure. So what we’re doing is we are actually taking transactions and we’re sending a proof onto Ethereum. So what that means is that we’re taking hundreds of thousands or even millions of transactions at any given time. We are effectively rolling them up, and then we’re sending a proof of those transactions, as opposed to the transactions themselves, onto Ethereum. A simple mental model to use, or simple comparison, is what a zip file does for data. I want to send you a PowerPoint presentation that’s 30 megabytes. I zip it up, it gets zipped up to 3 megabytes, and then I send it to you and it fits. We’re doing for compute, for compute power. So we’re taking hundreds of millions or tens of millions of transactions, rolling them up, and then we’re sending them onto layer one.
And so what that actually does for the users, their transactions are all recorded on layer one. And so when we talk about security of Ethereum, really security means the user’s ability to get their funds out if something goes wrong. So if StarkWare goes bust, or one of our customers goes bust, all of those transactions are recorded on Ethereum. A user can simply write to the smart contract on Ethereum and withdraw their funds. So we talk about security, that is what security means.
Another way of thinking about it is that it is self-custodial. So unlike exchanges, which hold your money, and we’ve seen what happens time and time again, FTX being the latest example, if a user is using an application that is on StarkEx, those funds are sitting in their wallet. It is a self-custodial system, and that’s really what security is. Security is a consumer’s ability to ensure that their funds are available to them at any given time, regardless of who the intermediaries are, whether it’s a crypto exchange, a perpetuals exchange, an NFT platform or StarkEx. Your money is always secure because you are self-custody it. We can talk a little bit more about the innovations that are happening there.
Dexter Cousins
Yeah, that would be great. It sounds to me like this is almost kind of like a quantum leap in the technology of being able to scale it, and yet haven’t really noticed anything much in the news about StarkWare. How have you kept this quiet?
David Engel
Well, we make a lot of noise in the Web 3 developer community, but we need to get better…
Dexter Cousins
Yeah.
David Engel
…at kind of at promoting ourselves. Said, look, this is a helpful opportunity to do it.
Just thinking back, talking back about your quantum leap, it absolutely is a quantum leap. So we are saving our customers up to a THX in gas fees for when they were writing directly onto Ethereum, so three orders of magnitude there. If I give a couple examples, dYdX, who is, I believe, the largest decentralised perpetuals exchange, they’re built on top of us. Before they were using our StarkEx platform, our zero knowledge proofs, they were spending 300,000 gas per transaction to settle that transaction onto Ethereum. When they moved across to us, they’re spending around 300 gas, so again a THX reduction.
Sorare, who does the NFT games for European soccer, Major League Baseball, the NBA, they’re now doing a World Cup edition as well, previously spent $1 million per week on gas fees to settle to Ethereum. Now that they’re on StarkEx, they’re spending 10,000 a week. So I’m actually kind of, this is an open question for people, to identify other three of magnitude improvements in technology. I think the printing press would be one, nuclear energy would be another, but there are not very many innovations where you get three order of magnitude improvement. So it really is a kind of a step change innovation.
Dexter Cousins
Yeah, and this solves the whole debate around using the technology for payments and instant payments. I mean, it’s kind of master it, right? There’s no debate now. Even here in our, where we’ve got, I’d say, a pretty advanced kind of instant payments system, there’s still in the back end a fair bit of clunkiness. This just seems slick.
David Engel
Yeah, so this will solve scalability for any application that wants to be built on Web 3. So payments is a great example. So the first thing that you do is, by creating decentralised payments, you remove the middle men. So you remove all of the different kind of rent-seeking players that are through that workflow, and so it becomes purely peer-to-peer. But even when it’s peer-to-peer, you need a platform that can handle the scale of a global payment network.
And so the idea is that a payment network built on StarkEx, which is our SaaS solution, or on StarkNet, which is the StarkWare and community built decentralised platform, will deliver the scalability that you can build the global payment network, or a social media platform, or decentralised identity. Any of those things can be built and scaled then on StarkEx or on StarkNet.
Dexter Cousins
I was in Singapore a few weeks ago for the Singapore Fintech Festival. It was very, very clear that certainly the kind of support for web3 technology, blockchain technology, to build the infrastructure, to build the world that going to need, not only for the future but to tackle these big problems around climate change, disparity around income, and to bridge all of these gaps, the role that Web 3 is going to play in that is huge.
And it’s kind of, the conversations around JPEGs and Punks and stuff kind of frustrates me a bit, because chatting with you is so energising, just to see the kind of the progress that’s being made, right, that, as I mentioned, never gets talked about. Talk about how much a Punk’s worth, but this is like the real use of the technology, solving so many different problems, as you mentioned, around identity, scaling payments. What would you say was the thing that, when you met with StarkWare, got you to go, right, that’s it, I’m joining these guys, like, absolutely into this vision?
David Engel
Look, to be honest, it was a bit of a journey. So when I moved to Israel, I actually met the CEO the first week that I was here. I was already very thoroughly redpilled, but I loved working with AWS and I wasn’t planning on leaving. And really, the more that I talk to people within the industry who I considered knowledgeable, the more people said that StarkWare really was the industry leader in building kind of Web 3 core infrastructure.
So the point that you made before around kind of monkey JPEGs drowning out the noise of the real technology builders, there are people that are building blockchain companies or assets because they want to promote the asset side of it. And the asset side of it is very important, because that’s what drives liquidity to the platform. That also has a very, very big downside, as we’ve seen. The other side is people who are building technology to build technology, and StarkWare is a deep, deep technology company. Most of the people that work for StarkWare, especially on the product and the technology side, care more about cryptography than they do about cryptocurrency. They just see that layer two zero knowledge proofs is the single best application for cryptography in the market where they can actually apply their trade.
And so the thing that makes me so bullish on StarkWare, and really ultimately that made me join, was just seeing both the community organic enthusiasm for the company, and seeing just how deeply focused it is on the technology and advancing the technology, and on being very disciplined about ignoring all the other noise that kind of comes with this industry.
Dexter Cousins
Yeah. Now, you know what a simple man I am. Can you explain to me ZK rollups?
David Engel
I’ll do my best. So as I said previously, a simple way to think about it is that it does for compute what a zip file does for data storage. And so let me unpack that a little bit. So compute on the blockchain, on Ethereum, is very expensive, compute being basically the power that you need to run any sort of application. So the previous innovation for compute was cloud computing. So when Amazon launched EC2 instances, what an EC2 instance is, is basically saying, rather than you doing compute on your server in your garage, if you’re in accounting firm, we’re going to do compute for you. And so AWS built up these massive, massive compute warehouses that are just full of servers to do compute.
So it is very cheap to do compute off-chain, but if you want to do compute on-chain on Ethereum, it is very, very expensive. So we talked previously about gas prices spiking and going to $21 to do a transaction. Basically that cost is a proxy for how expensive it is to do compute, or to solve transactions on Ethereum. And so what a zero knowledge proof does is we take all of that complex compute that was on-chain and was very expensive on-chain, and we do that compute off-chain. So we’re actually taking very complex transactions, dYdX perpetual transactions, where you’re tracking price movement of an asset every second, or being able to mint tens of millions of NFTs at a given time. If you do that on-chain is very expensive. Doing it off-chain, on the StarkEx platform, on StarkNet, it becomes orders of magnitude cheaper.
And what the zero knowledge aspect of that is, is saying, is taking all of those transactions, creating a cryptographic proof that those transactions are valid, so basically using math to prove that those transactions are valid, then rolling them up, or zipping them like a zip file would, and only sending a proof that those transactions happened on-chain, rather than all of the transactions themselves. And so hopefully that is a simpler way of understanding what zero knowledge proofs are and what they’re achieving.
Dexter Cousins
David, I’ve done, I think, nearly 250 of these interviews now. I don’t think I’ve been more genuinely excited by an innovation or kind of product or technology that we’ve had on this show. I mean, it’s just, it’s mind blown, right, just sitting here talking to you about what’s happening at StarkWare. I literally am kind of just lost for words, right, to how much of a leap this is. I guess, looking to the future and the year that you’ve had, what do you see happening in 2023, and what are kind of some of the plans for StarkWare?
David Engel
Yeah, so there’s a couple things that we’re looking forward to. Let me talk about on the StarkEx side, on our SaaS platform side. We are seeing a substantial increase in demand from exchanges and traditional FSIs that want to build non-custodial solutions. So this is a direct reaction to what happened at FTX, where FTX was custody users funds, and because they were custody user funds, they could effectively do what they wanted with them.
We’re now seeing substantial demand in self-custody, and self-custody has a couple aspects to it. One is what we’re hearing now is proof of reserves. So a lot of customers are talking about the need to prove that they have reserves on-chain. And the other aspect is that a user will always sign for their transaction. So you want to make sure that a user has the ability to digitally sign for the transaction. You can’t move the funds without them. So StarkEx, which is our SaaS platform, does that out of the box. So it is a self-custodial platform with proof of reserves built into the code. So one thing that we really look forward to seeing is just more customers, being banks and crypto exchanges, moving towards self-custody. So that’s the first one.
On the StarkNet side, so StarkNet is a decentralised blockchain platform that was developed both by StarkWare and by the community. It is a public good. On that, we really expect to see that to start to scale, to deliver kind of similar volume of transactions as what we’re seeing on StarkEx. The reason that we think that that’s going to happen is that we’re doing a couple new innovations. So we’re launching a new Cairo code. So Cairo is our native L2 programming language. That means that you can code your smart contracts in Cairo. It is optimised for layer two. We’re launching version 1.0, so we’re going to see a substantial increase in developer activity on that.
And then the third innovation that we are looking forward to is what we’re calling layer three. And so layer three is a private instance of StarkNet that customers can use to actually build on top of StarkNet, build on top of the permissionless layer two platform, but they will have ultimate control over who can access that instance of StarkNet, what the gas fees are on StarkNet, what they will write their own smart contract, so what they want to build on their layer three. And so we expect to see a lot of innovation happening on layer three, where you have banks or payment companies or social media companies that want to be able to control their own environment, but want to be able to build their own smart contracts, build their own applications using our programming language, Cairo.
So one is we expect to see an increase in self-custodial solutions building on StarkEx. Two is we expect to see an acceleration of innovation on StarkNet, on the permissionless public blockchain. And three is that we will launch layer three technology, apologies, we will launch layer three on top of StarkNet, which will allow large institutions or just centralised institutions to build their own applications on a private instance of StarkNet.
Dexter Cousins
I guess if we looked at kind of Web two technologies, I’m thinking e-commerce and payments businesses like Stripe and Shopify, it sounds almost like they’re going to be irrelevant pretty soon, the way they’ve been being able to scale this technology.
David Engel
No. Well, so the first thing is that you’re always going to need on Ramson off-ramps, right? So you always need the ability to get from fiat to crypto and from crypto to fiat. So payment companies will always serve a role in that, so that’s certainly not going away. And I think that’s on the payment side, on someone like Stripe. And then on the e-commerce side, effectively what you’re going to see is you’re going to see a lot of e-commerce companies, and Shopify has been very public about this, there’s podcasts about it, actually embracing the promise of Web 3. So a good use case would be token gating, where customers that have a particular NFT can now get access to new brands or new experiences or cross-sell opportunities for other brands.
So I wouldn’t say that they will be irrelevant, but they will adapt, and those that adapt the fastest and embrace the Web three technology, I think, will continue to thrive. I think on the other side is you’re going to see lot of net new companies that are building these technologies natively and that are starting with these technologies, and I think we will see an entire new host of startups and innovation that are kind of purely Web 3 native, and building on technologies like StarkNet.
Dexter Cousins
Yeah. It feels, having been around the fintech scene and the blockchain scene for close to a decade now, there’s almost like there’s a part of me that’s sad, because I feel like entering a new era. There a part me it’s really excited, because I know that there’s a new era coming. And it’s kind of, I feel like we’re leaving behind even the fintech 2.0 stuff, which was still building digital solutions for an analogue world, and we’re now seem to be very much that we’re kind of getting very close to the point in StarkWare is a great example of a digital solution for a digital world, where it’s a completely different way of looking product and solutions and infrastructure to what we’ve looked at previously.
You’ve been around the space, you’ve been around Australia, probably the equal amount of time as me. What’s your senses to kind of where the Aussie fintech space is at, and the blockchain space is at in Australia, and how do we kind of remain relevant and kind of keep evolving? Like, we’ve done a really good job so far, but does feel like there’s another step change coming, and we’ve got to kind of really grasp that as well.
David Engel
Sure. So I’ll answer a slightly different question before I talk about Australia specifically, which is your point around kind of, let’s call it, moving from fintech 2.0 to fintech 3.0, if we want to call it that. I think the difference that we’re going to see going forward, and credit to you, you’re embracing it, so I don’t really believe that you’re that sad. I actually think that you’re loving it.
Dexter Cousins
I’ve been, right, for the last 12 months. So actually it was December last year that I was like, I was like you, right, but I didn’t take the red pill, but it was just, this is something, but I can’t figure out what it is yet. And it’s only been in the last six weeks that I’ve gone, now this is it, this is, see it. And it was kind of interesting, just like speaking to Brian Collins earlier this year when we had him on the podcast, and we were talking about what they were seeing, and it was what I was seeing, and it’s, hey. And I’m very, very, I think got a very, very firm hypothesis now that Web 3 is the infrastructure that we build this whole new world on. That’s kind of how I see Web 3. That’s my interpretation of it.
David Engel
I think you’re exactly right, and I think that’s how we’re going to see fintech change is directly related to that. So fintech previously was really building really nice front ends on legacy infrastructure. So if I wanted to build a new credit card, I would build that on legacy infrastructure. If I wanted to connect to banks, I would build that on legacy infrastructure. If I wanted to build a international payment network, it was all on legacy infrastructure. So fintech was very limited by their ability to innovate based on the limitations of the legacy infrastructure that they were building on.
Web 3 is now going to change that, in that you are building new innovation, new front ends, on top of new infrastructure, on top of new backends. So I think that’s a really important insight, to understand just how much we’re going to see fintech, which is very much the consumer facing front end of financial services, change because of access to new backends. So I think dYdX is an amazing example of that. dYdX is a on-chain perpetuals exchange built on StarkEx, and that simply would not have been possible to build on legacy Web two infrastructure. So I think that’s the change that we’re going to see.
Dexter Cousins
Yeah, I love that. I love that example, actually. Sorry to interrupt. Kind of one of the kind of, I think, the break through kind of brain thoughts that I had was just to think of the amount of value that we have locked up in the world, even just things like supply chain logistics and trade finance, and the amount of time that it takes to actually release that, and what more of an efficient world we could have, just in business, around being able to unlock that value quick, rather than the processes that we go through now. So that dYdX example, I think, is just great way, kind of real-time re-evaluation of assets is, like, I think the value that you can unlock, right, through that process.
David Engel
Sure, sure. Yeah, I mean, exactly right. I mean, ultimately what you’re going to see is a completely new paradigm of capital efficiency, of how quickly and simply people can allocate capital to different assets, in a way that simply wasn’t possible before…
Dexter Cousins
Yeah.
David Engel
…when you had a whole bunch of intermediaries in between.
Dexter Cousins
I agree completely. This is where all the magic’s happening. So I completely agree. I think the more that we can get these messages out and have these conversations, I think, and the great thing about this podcast and the audience is, these are people that are in fintech, banking, financial services, institutions that are going to be using this technology in the next five years. I’ve got no doubt, right? It’s just going to happen.
David Engel
Absolutely, absolutely. Do you want to talk about Australia?
Dexter Cousins
I do. Yeah, yeah. I mean, you’ve obviously got a real love for the nation. I think pretty much everybody that I do… I was actually at dinner last night, was the Fintech Australia and ofier dinner, and it was kind of sad not seeing here there, to be honest. It’s not quite the same, right?
David Engel
Well, that’s very… No, the FOMO was real when I started Intersekt, and everybody talking about Intersekt. For those don’t know, Intersekt is a Fintech Australia annual event. There was real FOMO there. That was a time when I really missed Melbourne.
Dexter Cousins
Yeah, yeah. But yeah, look, I’d love to get your views on, first of all, Israel. And the question I’ve got for you on Israel is, is this kind of the mantra that it has around being this innovation nation, is that true or is it more hype?
David Engel
Oh, it’s absolutely true. I mean, the metric that really brought this home to me, and this was when I moved eight months ago, so it may have changed a little bit now. Israel is a country of 7 million people and it has 65 unicorns. Australia is a country of 27 million people, and I think it had five to seven unicorns. And Israel, other than Silicon Valley, has the most unicorns. It actually has the most unicorns per capita. But other than Silicon Valley, I think, and the UK maybe, the most investment dollars. For a country of seven million people is just absolutely mind-blowing.
So what can Australia learn from that? First of all, I think Australia does very well. This isn’t me saying that Australia isn’t doing well. I think that Israel is absolutely exceptional. I think Australia does and is embracing Web 3 very, very well. So there’s some great exchanges. BTC Markets, Swyftx are doing a good job in custody customer funds. Obviously you have Immutable, which is one of the absolute world leaders in NFT gaming. I think last quarter they did more sales than all of the quarters previously. So they’re just an amazing platform. They’re a wonderful customer of ours. They use StarkEx, which is the platform that I mentioned, to mint NFTs at scale in Web 3 gaming.
Another really interesting company is Canvas. So Canvas is a customer of ours. Out of their, they building DeFi pooling and DeFi for enterprise. So basically they’ve taken our StarkEx platform and they now starting to target enterprise banks, and they’re doing very, very well. I encourage people to have a look at them, either reach out to them or reach out to us, especially if you’re interested in how this can be applied to enterprise banking. So there’s great innovation happening in Australia.
What do I see in Israel that Australia can learn from? I think the first is that Israel is completely unhierarchical. So it is very meritocratic, in that anybody with good ideas gets a seat at the table and everybody listens. I think that Australia, especially in larger institutions, is still a bit hierarchical, which can tend to slow things down.
Israel is also deeply, deeply technical. So the innovations and the businesses that are built are deep, deep tech businesses, but the level of technical know-how spreads across the entire organisation. So one thing that I am so impressed by StarkWare is that people across your organisation who you wouldn’t think need to be technical understand the StarkWare technology at a very deep level. So our marketing lead has a deep understanding of the technology. Our finance lead has a deep understanding of technology. The BD team, I would be the least technical, and I’ve got a moderately good understanding of it. So it really is encouraged and embraced, and almost like a ticket to play, to be able to be deeply technical on these things. And it actually, from a BD perspective, it helps us sell better. To be kind of very mercenary about it, we can talk more deeply to customers, we can earn trust faster with customers, because we are so deeply technical. And that’s not necessarily unique to StarkWare within Israel. I think that that’s a trait of Israel.
And the third thing that I would say is that it is very, very solution oriented. So a problem that would potentially take other institutions three to five meetings, with 10 people in each meeting, to solve, I found that StarkWare solves in a single meeting. We get in, we go very direct towards a problem and we solve it very quickly, which just makes us faster. It makes us faster from a development perspective, from a BD perspective, from a marketing perspective. So I think those are just a couple things that I’ve noticed that are different in Israel, that I think would be great applied in Australia and elsewhere.
Dexter Cousins
So you don’t do coffees then?
David Engel
No, there not. I actually miss it, to be perfectly honest about it. I do miss the coffee culture. But no, you don’t. You get into a meeting, maybe you spend 15 seconds on niceties. Now everybody knows where I’m from, so they don’t even bother asking anymore, and you get straight into it. So there’s an element of that that I miss.
Dexter Cousins
That’s a good… Yeah. Now, before we wrap up, this is, I guess, a podcast as well that’s to help people get, I guess, more intrigued and interested in the space, who might not necessarily be in the space right now. What are some of the podcasts and the kind of resources that you went to as you were going down the rabbit hole, that really kind of helped you get a better understanding of Web 3?
David Engel
So there’s two things that people need to do who are interested. One is podcast, and I’ll talk about those. The other is Twitter. Twitter is an absolute wealth of information, if you can just make it through the noise. But let’s talk about podcasts first. Bankless is amazing. Empire is very good. There was a podcast called Common Core, which was done by Three Arrows Capital, which has since imploded, but their podcasts are actually very, very good and very deeply technical. If you want, probably the single best podcast on StarkWare is one that our co-founder Eli Ben-Sasson did on Common Core, with a guy named Hu. So people who want to learn more about StarkWare, that’s a great place to do it. Defiant as well is a very good podcast.
On Twitter, I’m not going to list all the good people that I follow on Twitter, but if you’re interested in this space, just go on Twitter, have a look at who I follow, have a look at who Dexter follows. Follow Dexter.
Dexter Cousins
I’m just posting about Elon Musk at the minutes.
David Engel
Yeah, but shitposting is part of it, right? I think shitposting is actually part of the culture of Twitter that I appreciate. So yeah, I would look at those. And the other thing is, this might be counterintuitive, but I would encourage people to stay away from necessarily reading books on blockchain, just because it moves so fast that by the time finish the book…
Dexter Cousins
Yeah.
David Engel
…what you’re reading is probably going to be slightly outdated or have moved on. So both the upside and the downside of Web 3 is the immediacy of it. It moves so, so quickly. But you kind of want to prioritise short form content over long form content, because it just is what’s going to keep you most up to date.
Dexter Cousins
Yeah.
David Engel
So that would be my recommendation.
Dexter Cousins
Awesome advice. Where can people get in touch with you?
David Engel
You can find me on Twitter. Yeah, I think Twitter is the best place to get in touch.
Dexter Cousins
Awesome. And look, before we wrap up, first of all, it’s been great to have you on the show, David, and just spend some time with you, and you really missed doing it in person, I’m going to be honest, right? I just can’t get over the kind of video stuff, especially with somebody I’ve known for so long. But if you look at 2023, what is the thing that’s got you most excited about in the Web 3 space?
David Engel
I think L2s are going to hit their stride. I think we’re really going to see the true scalability of blockchain. Layer twos are going to deliver that, and we’re very, very excited to play a part in that.
Dexter Cousins
Awesome. David, it’s been fantastic to have you on the show. I’m just like mind blown, finding out about StarkWare. I’ve got to say, I am really envious. I often look, when I’m given an opportunity by a client, and say, hey, if I was the right person, would I want this job? If I was offered the job that you’ve got right now, I would ditch everything that I’ve built to get on board. It just sounds incredible.
David Engel
That’s lovely to hear. That’s very nice to hear, and thank you for having me, Dexter, and thank you for doing this. I think that you are a very, very clear, convincing and concise voice in this space, and appreciate everything you’re doing to help educate everyone.
Dexter Cousins
Thanks, David. Been a pleasure to have you on.
David Engel
Great, Dex. Take care.
Dexter Cousins
Thanks for listening. If you want to connect with me, follow Dexter Cousins on LinkedIn and Twitter. If you’re coming back, thanks so much for your support, and if you’re new to the show, make sure to follow us and leave a review. Until the next episode, stay safe. This show is presented by Tier One People, leaders in fintech executive search. We find world-class talent to build world-class ventures, and you can find us at tieronepeople.com.


